I've made quite a few of each style and they do run big. Maybe I should say "roomy." I prefer the halter style on my girls, looks more fitted. I made a size 4 halter simply sweet and both DD9 and DD2 can wear it. My advice, go with the 6 in halter style and it will be sure to fit (for a few years) but won't look too big. This is the same dress on both girls:
I love the twirl but boy is it a lot of sewing... and with no ruffler, oh I feel faint! You are braver than me! DD9 loves them too and knows how much fabric is needed to make one and when she goes to the fabric store she picks out her own fabric and marches up to have it cut. I have a lot of twirls she wants me to make including a St. Patty's day one. Seems like a lot of work for one day. Plus I'm making one for the Big Give I need to get working on. Yours looks awesome!
I've missed a lot of other great stuff that has been posted, good work everyone!
Okay, so I made the pageboy hat from YCMT and I have to say "ahh." The directions are no CarlaC directions but they are fine. Although the sizing ws a little crazy. Based on the head measurements DD9 needed and XL. Made to measurements, it was way too big and I needed to adjust it a couple of times (thank goodness for my trusty seam ripper!) Its just that it doesn't look as cute on as it does in the photos or on the babies that I've seen posted here. I think because on babies it is lower on their head. That may account for the sizing being too big for my DD. To make it wearable on DD9 it needs to be fitted and that makes it somehow less cute. I'll take pics tomorrow.