Cozumel All Terrain vs Dune Buggy Excursions

[AU Dre]

Looking to see if anyone has done either the Dune Buggy and Beach Snorkel Combo (CZ23) or the All-Terrain Buggy and Snorkel (CZ57) while in port. I just wanted to see if anyone had done one of these before and had any advice/opinions on which one would be better.
Figure these are the closest to mixing something he might like along with the snorkeling i would like.
They look fairly similar so trying to figure if there is an advantage to one over the other.
Thanks for any help!

​

 

[soniam]

We did the dune buggy/snorkel years ago. The dune buggies weren’t kept in good shape. The brakes were bad in ours. My husband tried to handle it in the Cozumel traffic but ended up rear-ending another car. No one was hurt, and there really wasn’t any damage; it was very slow speed in bumper to bumper traffic. The dune buggy was windy and dusty. The snorkeling was from a beach and was crowded and cloudy. They had lunch in a beach, but there was a bunch of people trying to sell us stuff while we ate. This was almost 10 years ago, so it could have completely changed. I know it might not help with comparing though.

 

[AU Dre]

We did the dune buggy/snorkel years ago. The dune buggies weren’t kept in good shape. The brakes were bad in ours. My husband tried to handle it in the Cozumel traffic but ended up rear-ending another car. No one was hurt, and there really wasn’t any damage; it was very slow speed in bumper to bumper traffic. The dune buggy was windy and dusty. The snorkeling was from a beach and was crowded and cloudy. They had lunch in a beach, but there was a bunch of people trying to sell us stuff while we ate. This was almost 10 years ago, so it could have completely changed. I know it might not help with comparing though.

Thanks that does help. Really just looking to see if anyone had experiences with either option.