cookie exchange ideas? UPDATE it was a hit!

binny

do something that MATTERS!
Joined
Mar 14, 2001
Messages
14,933
Im hosting a cookie exchange again this year. 2 years ago when I last hosted one we had a blast and lots of people came. More than what I had planned for actually lol.


Have you ever hosted one? What do you enjoy most? Do you have a favourite cookie recipe that really goes over well?
I would love any help you can offer! :)
 
I've done cookie exchanges before, they're a lot of fun, but a lot of work! Chocolate chip cookies are always the favorites, especially when you mix it up a bit - use toffee bits, mint M&M's, peanut butter chips, ect. in place of regular chips. I did pumpkin cookies and lemon cookies one year - those were a hit! Good luck and have fun with it! You can find lots of great cookie recipes online, or those little soft-cover cookbooks they sell next the the registers at the grocery store always have great holiday cookie recipes. I know Pillsbury usually does one that is all Holiday Baking recipes. Good luck and have fun!!
 

I did one last year --- they are lots of fun. I freeze mine right away and don't get them out until Christmas eve - otherwise they would be all gone! I noticed in the Target #1 spot really cute baking things you could give as favors. They have a whoel baking aisle this year. Very cute!
 
2 recipes:

1 1/2 c sugar
1 1/2 c packed brown sugar
4 sticks butter
1 t vanilla
4 eggs
cream together
Mix 6 c flower and 1 t baking soda and then slowly add to above mixture.

Add 1 bag each of white chocolate chips, semi sweet chocolate chips, chocolate chunks and milk chocolate chips. Stir. Bake at 350 degrees for 10-12 min.

This makes an unbelievable amount of cookies and is one of the best I have had.

#2 2 pkg pilsbury peanut butter cookie rolls
reeses peanut butter cups...minis

Bake cookies in mini muffin pans as directed on package. Check during cooking because it may need less cooking time. Have the mini cups unwrapped and peeled and ready to go in the cookies the second you pull them out of the oven. I then place them in the freezer for a bit so they are easy to remove from pan. I make these every Christmas and people rave over them...if they only knew how incredibly easy they are. I have had the ones like this with Hershey kisses and they don't even compare. Have fun.
 
I host one at work. Since everyone has different schedules (we're open 7 days a week, mostly 12 hours a day), I make it so that even if someone can't be present for the exchange, they can still participate.(I volunteer to distribute and collect the cookies for anyone that isn't present).

Basically, the rule is that everyone bakes 1 dozen cookies for each participant. They do count themselves because the day of the exchange, we put out an array of cookies to share together (I usually provide milk and tea). The most we had was 12 participants. It sounds like a lot of cookies, but the secret is to find a recipe that yields more cookies. I try to find recipes that yield 4 or 5 dozen, so there's less batches to make. So everyone packages the cookies in the dozens, we swap, and you go home with x amount of different dozen cookies. We usually do this in mid-December. Some freeze the cookies to serve at their holiday parties. Or others like me, have their DH attack the cookie batch when I get home the day of the swap :rotfl:

As far as my favorite recipes go, I love the Nestle toll house website. They have some great recipes that are yummy.

Also, sometimes someone will split their batch and make 6 dozen of one kind and 6 dozen of another. As long as they bring in a dozen per person, it doensn't matter.
 
I wanna come to the cookie exchange - but you live too far away..:(

I LOVE baking cookies and usually make enough that I could host a cookie exchange every single day for the whole month of December - and on!! :teeth:
 
C.Ann said:
I wanna come to the cookie exchange - but you live too far away..:(

I LOVE baking cookies and usually make enough that I could host a cookie exchange every single day for the whole month of December - and on!! :teeth:

Me too!

We used to have one at work - we had to be VERY FIRM with some people that NO BOUGHT cookies were allowed.

I made pralines one year - as a special treat as they are not as easy to make as cookies. This was in California, and no one knew what they were. They did not go over at all like I had hoped.
 
We like to request that each participant seperate the cookies byt the dozon (in a bag or something) & attach a copy of the recipe. Cookie exchanges can be a lot of fun, as long as everyone follows the rules. :)
 
Binny - I made these this weekend, kind of to test out the recipe, as I needed something for my DD's cast party and a church bake sale. They were absolutely delicious. And, the bonus - they were incredibly easy.

I happen to have a pastry bag and the right tips, but if you don't I would think a little "dallop" of frosting would suffice - and only you would know that it called for a star tip dallop of frosting.

Mint Petites

¼ cup sugar
1 cup (2 sticks) butter, room temperature
About a dozen foil wrapped rectangular chocolate mints (such as Andes)
¼ to ½ teaspoon peppermint extract
½ teaspoon vanilla extract
2 cups bleached or unbleached flour
½ cup Pillsbury milk chocolate frosting supreme

Preheat oven to 375 degrees.

In a large bowl, beat sugar and butter with mixer until light and fluffy.
Add peppermint extract and vanilla; blend well. Lightly spoon flour into measuring cup; level off. Add to dough and stir in, mixing well, using hands if necessary.

Shape dough into ½- to ¾-inch balls.

Place on ungreased cookie sheets; flatten slightly.

Bake in preheated oven 10 to 12 minutes or until edges are lightly browned. Cool 1 minute, then remove from cookie sheets onto brown paper. Cool completely.

Unwrap chocolate mints; cut mint in half crosswise, then diagonally in half to form small triangles.

Frost cookies using a pastry bag with star tip. Top each with chocolate mint triangle so it stands up. Makes 3½ dozen.

(Just a couple of notes - I made a double batch, and would have needed just over a can of frosting, except, we just had the remaining 8 at home without the frosting/mints. It was harder than I thought it would be to cut the mints, and we only used 1/2 mint on each cookie instead of 1/4 of a mint. And my last comment - if you need to make a bunch (i.e. many dozens) make and bake the cookies now, and they will easily freeze. Take them out the night before you actually need to decorate them. The frosting and the mint part takes hardly any time at all.)

Have fun at your exchange!
 
This is one of my favorite cookie recipes, I think it was from Southern Living.

Chocolate Chunk Coffee Cookies

2 C. plus 2 T. flour
½ t. soda
½ t. salt
¾ C. margarine
2 T. coffee
1 C. firmly packed brown sugar
½ C. sugar
1 egg
1 egg yolk
1 pkg. mega-morsels

Combine 1st 3 ingredients. Combine butter and coffee in small saucepan. Heat until melted. Cool to room temperature. Combine butter mixture, sugars, egg, egg yolk in large bowl. Beat at medium speed – gradually add flour until blended. Stir in morsels. Drop by heaping tablespoon onto ungreased cookie sheet. Bake 325 for 12-14 minutes.


I love cookie exchanges, they are one of my favorite holiday parties! :goodvibes
 
Thank you all so much! Some great ideas and some great recipes! We decided to do it on 12-3 so I could still use some more input. Im going to work on invitations tomorrow, anyone have any good ideas for those?

I will print out a list of "rules" to go in them but would love to hear any suggestions for invitations.

Thanks again!
 
We used to do one every year. Everyone brought their cookies already wrapped 6 to a small paper plate. Then we set out all the plates and as many plates as you brought was how many you could take. Most people brought 4 to 6 dozen. So you got a really great selection... 6 of each.

My favorite is to make "Candy Cane Cookies"
(Nothing fancy right out of the Betty Crocker cookbook)
Basiclly sugar cookie dough. Divide in half. Add red food coloring to one half.
Roll a teaspoon of each color into two ropes, wrap together and bend the top to look like a cane. Bake. Then while still warm top with some crushed candy cane. Yumm... and they're so cute.
 
I'm hosting one this year. I used Robins Rules for the most part. I liked her ideas about no "no bakes", and must have flour. It does level the playing field and no one feels like they spent hours while someone else may have only spent a few minutes.

There are 12 of us and we'll make 7 dozen cookies, (1/2 dzn for each and some for the party). Since we are all scrapbookers, we are also making 5x7 scrapbooked recipe cards. I'll do 12, all the same, of my Orange Snowball recipe, and everyone else will do 12 of theirs and we'll swap cookies and recipes. Then we'll have a little party and scrapbook till midnight!

Everyone is so excited...I get emails from them everyday about who's bringing what and what paper they're using for the recipe card! :goodvibes
 
I'm going to MIL's annual cookie exchange this weekend and I can't decide what to make. I was thinking about making either peanut butter bon-bons or cookie dough bon-bons. I wanted to do something different, but these are not technically cookies. Everyone seems to make the same thing every year and I don't have my "signature cookie" yet.

Are no bake cookies or treats a definite No-No? They're not easy or cheap to make, and are really good. Plus they keep so well.
 
Although these are not "cookies" they are wonderful and oh-so easy to make!!

Using a small muffin pan which is greased well make up a box of brownies (according to their direction) put brownie batter 1/2 full in each muffin cup and then place an unwrapped reeses peanut butter cup in the middle. Bake at temperature for the browines for about 20 minutes.

These are such a hit!!
 
princess momma said:
Are no bake cookies or treats a definite No-No? They're not easy or cheap to make, and are really good. Plus they keep so well.
It all depends on the party! My mom hosted one for 10 years or so at work, and their big rules were
1. NO store-boughts.
2. NO chocolate chip.

That's right...NO CHOCOLATE CHIP! They figured anybody can buy a back of chocolate chips and follow the recipe on the bag....they wanted something different and pretty and impressive....something you'd be proud to see out at a Christmas party :) They had lots of gorgeous, delicious cookies every year....Mmmmm!

Hoping to start this tradition someday myself, so enjoying everyone's suggestions! :)
 
well it was a huge hit!!

I had 12 women total so it was a nice size group.

Lots of good cookies too!

The pre bagging idea is the only way to go! Everyone got the right amount of cookies so that was nice. I did 2 games the one where you pick a slip of paper out of the bix and then answer the question that was a lot of fun and went over really well. Then we did the left right game, that was hilarious!

I had a nice mix of people some who knew each other and some who didnt but everyone really hit it off.

I think it went really well everyone seemed happy and said they couldnt wait for next year!


Now I can relax for a couple of weeks until MIL gets here at least.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom