Comfort Suites Maingate was surprisingly nice, we thought. It's at 7888 W. Irlo Bronson Hwy. We stayed there one night when we couldn't extend our condo in March 2007. The pool area was quite nice, and the room was decent. I believe it's right across the street from the Best Western mentioned in the post above, and I agree that either of these would be the closest to AK. I'm pretty sure the Comfort Suites is much newer.
One more question/requirement-which of these hotels have bell services or the like. We will be arriving in am after cruise and will need to check our luggage before going to Animal Kingdom?
Thanks for info on Best Western. We have always stored our luggage when checking in if room was not ready or checking out and staying later, but this has been at Disney, Sheraton, Hyatt, Westin and other resorts. I will call and see, otherwise I may have to do Pop for more money. Hate to pay that to store luggage.