We are the opposite of the pp in one respect that we have also stayed at both resorts, but CL at the WL and a regular GV room at the Poly. My favorite CL is GF RPC, with WL CL ranking a very close second to that. Both resorts are great, with the Poly having an edge over the WL for us in that the Poly rooms are quite a bit larger with every room having a daybed (which is nice with having 2 teens). But if the WL rooms were comparable in size with a daybed, we would have a tough time choosing between the two. As far as CL at the WL, we thought the food offerings were great and the CMs were awesome. The WL doesn't really have a lounge as the seating goes around the 7th floor railing, which overlooks the lobby, but I personally like that set up. Some people don't care for that, but I like it since it's unique and not your every day lounge, and it's nice sitting up there watching the goings on in the lobby down below. With all of that said, I don't think you can go wrong with either one as both the WL and Poly are awesome resorts, each with things unique to its own resort theming/decor.