I've read mixed opinions on this. Some have reported they were able to get the soup and breadsticks, others say they were refused. I have an ADR for LeCellier for my November trip so it doesn't matter than. But for February they aren't on my list of places we're eating. So I told DD (who is the soup fanatic in our house) that we would ask at the podium. I figure the worst thing they can do is say no.