I think if you can get a code and get a discount for a moderate you would have more fun at CBR than the Allstars, its nicer....well at least for us it is...we don't have kids and we spent about 1/2 our time at the resort because we had perfect weather and we just love to relax and sit by the pool, plus we tried the water mice and other stuff they have at CBR, so paying alittle more for CBR was really worth it for us, but if you don't plan to be around the resort much, then I guess Allstars is cheaper...just depends on if you can get a code for the time you are going.