Cap'n Jack's or Olivia's

[chill]

I thought the AR's were all set, but looking at changing; need recommendations for Cap'n Jacks or Olivia's. Cast Me, 3 boys;12,9,8

Thanks.

 

[danny1649]

O'Livia's,I don't care for Cap'n Jacks's

 

[disney queen]

olivia's hands down!

 

[cubanor]

Olivia's..........not a fan of CJacks.

 

[sotoalf]

Capt Jack's is vile - the worst restaurant in WDW (do a search if you want to see what the responses over the years have been like). It might work if you just want drinks and appetizers.

 

[Patty3]

I would definitely stay away from Cap'n Jack's.

 

[disney queen]

run run as fast as you can away from captn jack.

 

[BibbidyBobbidyBoo]

Wow, we loved Capt Jacks for dinner (yummy appetizers and dessert- yummy lobster dinner!) on our last trip and we're making a special effort go to there again on the next trip because of it!

I'm curious- can you make AR's for capt jacks? I thought it was walk up only? LMK please!

 

[Uncleromulus]

Olivia's is the much better choice.

 

[Hopefully]

I do not beieve that you can make ADR's at Cap'n Jack's

 

[Pocahontas1]

We ate at Olivia's last month and had one of our best meals of our trip. I would definitely recommend Olivia's. Everything was excellent. The atmosphere was laid back and the servers were very good. We will definitely go back to Olivia's.

 

[Kim&Chris]

Olivia's is Disney's best kept secret.

 

[beccasmom]

That’s an easy one! Olivia’s is wonderful and one of our absolute favorites! Breakfast is delightful, as is lunch, which can be ordered until 5:00 p.m. Dinner is also great, but offers less variety, IMHO. Dinner has a heavier influence on seafood.

The offerings at lunch include burgers, salads, soups, chicken, club sandwiches, vegetarian dishes, etc. They have great milkshakes and the desserts can easily be shared, as they are huge! Great service and a lovely, relaxed setting. An underrated gem!

 

[RobtG]

I agree on Olivia's. Ate there on my last trip and it'll be one of my first AR's on my next trip.

Enjoy!!