I made the life-altering mistake of clicking on this link eariler this morning (

) and I have a question. I've avoided reading the rest of the thread to avoid spoilers, but I'm really stumped about this part:
I got the frog statue down from the shelf, and he had two marbles in his eyes - a yellow one and a blue one. The blue one came out, and I looked at it with that little box thingy, and it had a perspective of the room from the plant shelf. So I'm obviously supposed to put the frog statue on that shelf, with his face pointing towards the clock. Ok so far. Since he's now sitting on a spotlight, I turned the lights on, thinking the light would somehow "activate" him. But nothing happens.
My question is this: While I was able to get the blue marble from his eye socket, I cannot get the yellow one. I've clicked and clicked and clicked, but i won't come out. Is it supposed to?
I've also tried putting the blue one back in the original eye socket - nothing. Replaced it with the green - still nothing. What the heck am I doing wrong?!?!