We tried this one once but would not do it again. The character interaction was great, but it was hot (we were there in mid Sept), the mosquitos were bad and the food was not very good. It was BBQ chicken, corn on the cob,etc. We took a boat ride from maybe the WL (can't remember) and the bugs were terrible. It was light going over but very dark on the way back. We stood on the dock and waited for a boat, but couldn't talk because the bugs were flying in our mouths.
If character interaction is the key for you, it doesn't get much better. There are no CM's guiding the characters. They just come out and dance and have fun. There were a few kids who kind of hogged the characters. The kids can kind of run wild while the parents are sitting on the picnic type benches.
I too preferred the Hoop Dee Doo and my kids 2 and 6 loved that too.