lurkyloo
The Attic was just perfect!
- Joined
- Aug 24, 2006
- Messages
- 15,682
I posted this in the massive cake thread, but here it is again if you don't want to wade through 85+ pages....
So a few months ago I got all agitated when I heard Disney had jacked up the price of the 6-inch non-custom cakes you can order at the restaurant podium to $21 and then outsourced them to Sara Lee.
Then I found out that only parks and resorts without their own bakery were serving Sara Lee cakes, so I decided to do a taste test of both kinds of cakes and report back....
Cake Made By WDW Resort Bakeries
This was a measly 3 inches high (it looked like an EasyBake Oven cake!) and tasted like a stale Twinkie covered in whipped cream...
I ordered it from our server at Coral Reef restaurant, which uses Epcots bakery.
Cake Made By Sara Lee
This was the size of a cake youd buy at a grocery store about 6 inches high and tasted like one too. The frosting was thick buttercream and the cake was moist. I ordered it at the podium at Tonys Town Square in the Magic Kingdom.
I happen to think grocery store cakes are decent for what they are and what they cost, and I hate whipped cream frosting, so thats the way this taste test skewed.... I declare Sara Lee cake the WINNER!!!

So a few months ago I got all agitated when I heard Disney had jacked up the price of the 6-inch non-custom cakes you can order at the restaurant podium to $21 and then outsourced them to Sara Lee.
Then I found out that only parks and resorts without their own bakery were serving Sara Lee cakes, so I decided to do a taste test of both kinds of cakes and report back....
Cake Made By WDW Resort Bakeries
This was a measly 3 inches high (it looked like an EasyBake Oven cake!) and tasted like a stale Twinkie covered in whipped cream...


Cake Made By Sara Lee
This was the size of a cake youd buy at a grocery store about 6 inches high and tasted like one too. The frosting was thick buttercream and the cake was moist. I ordered it at the podium at Tonys Town Square in the Magic Kingdom.

I happen to think grocery store cakes are decent for what they are and what they cost, and I hate whipped cream frosting, so thats the way this taste test skewed.... I declare Sara Lee cake the WINNER!!!
