We have been twice and really liked it however if you are staying at NewYork as I think you are you may find the breakfast is of a similar quality there (we did it when we were at santa fe and DCR)
The first time we did it we did the early sitting and I didnt eat much at all and really we wanted to get into the park.
The 2nd time we did the 2nd sitting and I preferred this - we went in for EMH- did lots of rides, built up an appetite and then enjoyed our breakfast. We didnt feel we needed to rush so lingered and relaxed