Boma, Jiko, Whispering Canyon, San Angel, Calif Grill, Tutto Italia, Teppan Edo

copperbrick

DIS Veteran
Joined
Jul 9, 2008
Messages
658
I also have a review of Animal Kingdom Lodge at: http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=1950017

Boma, Jiko, Whispering Canyon Cafe, San Angel Inn, California Grill, Tutto Italia, and Teppan Edo -- there are also a few counter service reviews at the end for Wolfgang Puck, The Mara, Norway Kringla Bakeri og Kafe and The Land's Sunshine Food Fair.

Who traveled: My adult daughter and me (Mom) Dates: Aug 31 - Sept 9 -- Hubby had to cancel due to work, but we already have another vacation booked for him and me!

When it comes to dining, I’m rather like a female version of American Idol’s Simon -- quite a critic. Even the finest restaurants get constructive comments from me, including many of the top restaurants in America.

That said, some well-crafted mac & cheese or a good hamburger and fries can rate as high or higher with me as the posh stuff - I'm a foodie and a critic, not a snob. : )

Most of the time, my daughter and I sampled each other’s orders so I was able to taste double - fun!

As you read, you will see I did not send anything back to the kitchen if I was unhappy with the preparation.

I am not at all shy about sending food back, but I was on vacation. The food was good or better everywhere, and I didn’t want to hassle with complaining. Exception: California Grill. I was wrong not to send my steak back. More later.

Note (added Sept 2009): Since going to WDW last year I have been diagnosed as gluten-intolorant, as you'll see in my signature. If you see that I made gluten-filled choices and wonder why, it is because I did not yet know that I needed to be tested for Celiac disease.
Here we go . . .

Jiko: WE LOVED IT!

Service: Impeccable. Server: Michelle

Atmosphere: Very Good, warm and relaxing (Wine Room, see below)

Food: Excellent

This is now my favorite restaurant in Disney (Victoria and Albert’s second). The food pairings and sauces were genius.

Bread basket: Excellent. Spiced butter a perfect paring with two distinctly different flavor breads - one sweeter and one savory with caraway - the butter was truly a brilliant taste match.

Appetizers:
Lamb "Patis" - Excellent.

Artisan Cheese Selection: Excellent. It came with the names of the cheeses as well as a little history - I appreciated this as it will allow me to research where to buy them online.

Wine: As you may know, Jiko has a wonderful wine list. Be sure to ask for suggestions based on your dining selections and DEFINITELY ask for tastes before ordering. I tried three tastes before deciding on the right wine - I thought I knew what I wanted, but the server’s suggestion proved superior and was available by the glass.

Main course:
Maize-crusted and Seared Halibut: Very good, but I would try something different next time.

The halibut was cooked perfectly but it could have been warmer. I also would have liked the crusty strips on top of halibut to have been crunchier - they had crunch but tasted as though they may have been softened a bit by the humidity or the steam off the fish.

Oak-Grilled Filet Mignon: Excellent, but not the best steak we would have in Disney, as you’ll see - I had this steak after having the better one, so I was prejudice at this point.

I’d still rate Jiko’s filet mignon a 9 out of 10, though! The meat was cooked perfectly. The oak grilled flavor is just right - not too overpowering - just enough. Mac and Cheese (no where near the same as Boma’s and soooo much better) was fabulous. I would be very happy ordering this dish again.

Vegetable “of the moment” as Jiko calls it: A nice blend of daily-fresh vegetables prepared properly. I have difficulty digesting some vegetables, and Jiko was careful to take care of me.

Dessert: House-made Lemon Curd with sour cream ice cream: Very good - if you are a fan of lemon curd, this is probably a must. I liked it, but it didn’t knock me over - I will try something different next time. Biscotti: Not crisp enough. Humidity again?

Tip: We dined in The Wine Room -- a small room off the main room. (Eight tables, maybe ten? -- not sure.) I did not know about this room. We found it peaceful, beautiful, and I would request it again.

The Wine Room may not be for everyone -- it is more secluded and away from all windows. Also, because this space is more intimate, a whining child would be more noticeable here than in the main seating area. Just added: if you read further in down this thread, seasoned Jiko fans suggest definitely requesting seats in The Cooking Place. -- This is probably a good tip and something I will remember next time.

San Angel Inn - a surprising WOW. I never expected it!

Atmosphere: Outstanding

I hadn’t booked San Angel Inn until my daughter requested it - my family dined there on our last trip (many years back), and we wanted to experience different restaurants this time around.

However, when my daughter told me San Angel was one of her favorite memories from her trip . . . I booked it again, of course!

When we went to San Angel previously, we had lunch instead of dinner. It was very good but -- aside from the atmosphere -- nothing big-time memorable.

So, I didn’t really expect to like San Angel’s food all that much. My family and I are spoiled by the outstanding authentic Mexican food we eat regularly in Chicago, New Mexico and California (okay, okay . . . we haven’t been to Mexico yet . . . but we’re working on it!).

Plus, while I’ve seen some rave reviews by San Angel fans, most aren’t screaming about it from the rooftops. I thought, “Okay, this will be a nice Mexican dinner in a beautiful room and my daughter will love being there.”

It was so much more!

Margarita on the rocks: Excellent.

Chips and Salsa: The chips were fresh, crisp - very good. The salsa was bland and unexciting at first . . . it was way too mild for me and didn’t even have enough flavor for my daughter who doesn’t like heat. I can appreciate Disney wanting to serve salsa this way - I imagine many tourists and their children are not accustomed to spicier foods.

So, I asked the server if San Angel had salsa with more kick. She smiled and said she’d take care of us. She was so sweet and caring, and she really seemed to appreciate our wanting flavors that were more authentic.

She brought two more salsa’s - one with much more flavor and more heat - wonderful -- and another very thick salsa with a lot of chipotle (great taste!) and quite hot. Both were excellent. I enjoyed the middle one best as did my daughter (she mixed it with the original mild). I will always ask for it.

Filete Motuleno (Grilled beef tenderloin over black beans and melted cheese, sauce ranchero, poblano pepper strips and fried plantain). My daughter ordered this. Thank goodness she shared. It was outstanding.

Okay, so right here you need to know I eat a lot of steak. Business finds me eating at the finest steak houses in the United States - Chicago especially and also New York, Kansas City, etc. My daughter used to work as a server in fine dining . . . she knows her steak too.

The Filete Motuleno blew us away - we agreed it is the best steak we’ve eaten ANYWHERE. It was an outstanding cut of meat -- ordered medium rare and cooked perfectly.

This was such a huge surprise! We both scored this dish a 10.

Next is not so good but because of me: Sugerencia Del Chef (Chef's Suggestions): The chef’s suggestion that night was a lamb dish served atop cheese, which was fair but also my fault:

I was not asked how I wanted the lamb prepared. The lamb came pre-sliced, which probably would have given me no choice as to how it was cooked. It came well-done as it would under those circumstances.

I do not like meat well-done. I should have known better. The server (who continued to be wonderful and didn’t miss a beat) was careful to ask my daughter how she wanted her steak prepared. Her lack of asking me about the lamb should have been a give-away, and I should have questioned her about the preparation before I ordered it - I take the blame for this one.

Dessert: Vanilla ice cream with cinnamon-sugar fried tortillas. The ice cream was smooth, rich and the tortillas fresh and crisp. Good!

I will definitely go back to San Angel. My only concern is that the steak was so perfect I wonder if any steak can be that good again . . . I look forward to trying!

Whispering Canyon Café:

Food: What we ordered was a little heavy and rich for the end of a sweltering day, but most of it was very good.

Service: Excellent.

We had the Canyon Skillet All You Care to Enjoy: Mixed greens with apple vinaigrette dressing, fresh baked cornbread with mashed potatoes, coleslaw, cowboy beans and seasonal vegetables (corn on the cob that night). Smoked pork ribs, pulled pork, oven-roasted chicken, Peel-n-Eat shrimp.

The ribs, cornbread, potatoes, chicken, shrimp were very good. I did not have any salad (daughter liked it) or coleslaw.

The pulled pork lacked flavor and was too tender-mushy for my taste.
Corn on the cob: Again, a little overcooked for me, but it was flavorful and fine.

This is A LOT of heavy food and more than my daughter and I found we wanted. Had my husband been able to make this trip, he would have enjoyed the food, especially the ribs and mashed potatoes.

Whispering Canyon was delicious, fun, and a chuckle. I’m glad we went. It is loud with a lot of server / guest interaction, which I expected and enjoyed. One time to "see the show" is enough for me, though . . . if we go again, we will request a seat in the back area away from all the participation.

Boma

NOTE before reading this: We went to Boma a second time in 2009 AND LOVED IT. One of our favorite restaurants, and the Domes were much better, too.

Back to last year's review . . .

Food: Need to try it again next time. Some choices were disappointing.
Atmosphere: Fair - open kitchen is enjoyable, though.

I had originally booked Boma three times. After dining there once (first night), I cancelled the remaining two reservations and ate elsewhere (San Angel and Teppan Edo).

I had triple-booked Boma because of the convenience of being in our hotel and because I heard so many wonderful things about it. Also, had my husband been able to make it, he likes buffets.

I’m not big on buffets - the lines and noise aren’t usually worth it to me.

The food was good with some interesting flavors. Many of the flavors could have been "kicked up a notch" (not heat this time, just the spices) - the recipes were good but hold the potential of being better.

Some choices didn’t wow me as nearly as much as I hoped, including the dessert Zebra Domes, which are rich and creamy and I can see why they are popular -- but - and maybe I should give them a second try - the Domes tasted like preservative-laced-semi-artificial-ingredient assembly line dessert food to me. The covering was a little waxy, too. Sorry Dome fans! I know I’m in the minority here. : )

The soup was excellent. So was the cheesecake.

There is a lot I didn’t taste because I was full and very tired. We never made it to the meat station, so I really can’t give a fair review of Boma here. I look forward to trying it again next trip.

California Grill:

Service: Outstanding

Atmosphere: Outstanding

Food: Disappointing

Bread basket: Sour dough bread was very disappointing. It did not begin to compare to California sour dough . . . or even Panera Bread for that matter!

Appetizer: Sonoma Goat Cheese Ravioli with Sun-dried Tomatoes, Pesto, Shiitake Mushrooms, and Basil: Good, not great.

Oak-fired Filet of Beef with Boniato Mashed Potatoes, Sautéed Haricot Vert and Teriyaki Barbeque Sauce: Good flavor, poor preparation.

Our steaks were fired unevenly - I ordered rare. It was medium rare in the middle and very well done a good portion into the sides. Daughter’s was also very well done on the sides (she ordered med rare).

The meat was not nearly as tender as at the other restaurants we tried, and we found ourselves wishing for steak knives -- they did not bring them, I assume intentionally as a gesture to show they "knew" the steak would be suitable for a butter knife.

Not.

We both should have sent our steaks back, but we had a window seat overlooking Wishes (which had just begun) and it wasn’t worth spoiling the moment. This was the end to our first full day at Disney and needed to be free of "baggage."

I will never eat a full dinner at the California Grill again. It is so not worth the double table credits. However, I would definitely visit there for a drink and a different appetizer.

When we arrived, our table was not ready. My daughter spotted a small table in the lounge where we decided to wait - it was right next to the window and gave us a perfect view of the Castle!

The server told us we were welcome to order dinner in the lounge, so we stayed at the same table. This alone made dining at CG worthwhile.

Peachy Keen Peach Cheesecake, Bellini "Bubble Tea", Spiced Tea Cake with Vanilla Crème Glace: Good, not great.

Valrhona Chocolate Cake and Apricots Warm Chocolate Cake with Molten Center, House-made Apricot Ice Cream: Good, not great. Much better than Peachy Keen, above.

Tutto Italia
Food: Very good

Service: Very good but rushed.

Our main dishes arrived in what felt like minutes after ordering them - many might appreciate this, especially with so much touring to do. I would have preferred a little more time. We did linger over a glass of wine and take a little longer than most to decide on what to order. This is a busy place and I’m sure they wanted to move the tables quickly.

Bread basket: Very good as was the herbed butter. They forgot to give us olive oil and we forgot to ask.

Sacchetti - pasta pillows filled with ricotta and mozzarella cheese and pomdoro sauce: Very good - pasta cooked perfectly. I enjoyed this and ate every bite!

Cannelloni al Forno - baked with spinach, ricotta, béchamel and parmesan cheese: Daughter had this - she loved it. I tasted it and wished I could eat more (I cannot have spinach) - very good.

Copetta Sotto Bosco - berries, zabaglione cream gelato and chocolate sauce. Very good - I ate every bite of this, too. I might experiment with something different next time.

Coffee: They use an outstanding Italian blend and bring the whole pot - wonderful! If you love good coffee, it is a must with dessert.

Teppan Edo

Service: Excellent

Atmosphere: Very good (pavillion is outstanding as are the gardens)

California Roll: Very good

Asakusa - sirloin steak and large shrimp: Very good - steak and shrimp were excellent -- flavorful with good sauces on the side. Both steak and shrimp were cooked perfectly. The side dish noodles were a little overcooked for my taste.

Fruit Tart: Fair. Much better at Sunshine Season Food Fair (see quick service, below)

Chocolate Ginger Cake: Excellent. This and the Boma cheesecake were my favorite desserts this trip.

My daughter loves Japanese steak houses so I swapped one of the Boma nights for it - Teppan Edo is wonderful and I would recommend it to all. I would not go there again only because we have similar restaurants close to where I live.

Quick service:

West Side Wolfgang Puck Express:

Daughter ordered four cheese pizza and said it was good but she’s had better.

I had a beef and cheese sandwich (cannot find it in the online menus and I forgot the name), and I did not like it. The bread was fair and the filling was cold and tasteless. It was supposed to be served cold - I didn’t realize this and was disappointed from the first bite on. I don't remember if the menu said it would be served cold.

I would not go there again.

Animal Kingdom Lodge Mara: Quick service here is very good. The couscous is outstanding.

Epcot, Norway: Kringla Bakeri og Kafe: Wonderful salmon sandwich on good bread. The pastry / dessert school bread is equally good.

Epcot: The Land: Sunshine Season Food: This is a food court. We loved it here and would make a point to eat here again. The fruit tart was amazing - FABULOUS crisp crust that didn't come close to being soggy and the fruits on top were lfresh and lush -- this can be tough to do in quick service. The minestrone soup was outstanding -- how I wished I didn't have vegetable dietary restrictions (I tasted my daughter’s) -- this is the best minestrone soup we have had anywhere.

That's all for now. I will add info as I remember it. Many thanks to Disney for a wonderful vacation!

I also have a review of Animal Kingdom Lodge at: http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=1950017
 
Thank you for your reviews! We are eating at almost all of the places you mentioned (for our trip next month) and I appreciate everything you had to say! Welcome home!
 

Great reviews.
Jiko is my favorite too :cloud9:
Isn't Michelle a doll? Can you believe she gave birth to twins about a year ago??
The service and food and ambiance there is delightful.
Next time sit at The Cooking Place, the bar in the center of the restaurant where the first courses are prepped. It's fun and you will learn a lot.
The Wine Room is my least favorite for a regular meal but I'm glad you enjoyed it. I have been to many wine dinners in that room and those are amazing but for dinner I like to be out in the "action" ;)
Thanks again for the great reviews! (I too love Sunshine Seasons :lovestruc )
 
Great reviews.
Jiko is my favorite too :cloud9:
Isn't Michelle a doll? Can you believe she gave birth to twins about a year ago??
The service and food and ambiance there is delightful.
Next time sit at The Cooking Place, the bar in the center of the restaurant where the first courses are prepped. It's fun and you will learn a lot.
The Wine Room is my least favorite for a regular meal but I'm glad you enjoyed it. I have been to many wine dinners in that room and those are amazing but for dinner I like to be out in the "action" ;)
Thanks again for the great reviews! (I too love Sunshine Seasons :lovestruc )

Hi, Johnsonet:

Great to see you here! I always enjoy reading your posts.

Twins? Wow -- server Michelle really does look great. It's nice to hear back from someone who's also had her as a server.

I will request the cooking place as you suggest -- also, I noticed on the lodge activity sheet that at 4:00 PM most days they have a tour of Jiko for adult lodge guests -- have you ever taken it?

I wanted to do the tour very much but just couldn't seem to get back to the hotel in time each day.

Thank you for your suggestions!
Copper
 
Great reviews - thanks for sharing! :)

Keep in mind tho that like you said, the other guests in the wine room at Jiko can make or break your time there. We are regular visitors and were last there in August. We were seated in the wine room which at first I thought was great. Then we got to experience our neighbors. Since we were the only two groups in there we were more aware of them. It was two families on the long table with 5 or 6 kids between them. The kids were basically well-behaved, but, well, they were kids! And I think the privacy of the room let the parents give them more freedom so they were up and about and chasing each other around the table and such. It took away from the feel of the restaraunt for us and next time we will ask to be seated in the main area.

Jill
 
Thanks for the reviews. What a shame the food at California Grill was disappointing.
 
Thanks for sharing your reviews with us, may have to put San Angel back on the try again list!:goodvibes
 
Great reviews. Loved the format. I am trying Jiko on my next trip and now I REALLY can't wait.

Hubby loves Mexican...San Angel may get added to my ADR list!
 
Thanks for the reviews, they are awesome! I know what you mean about the Filete Motuleno, I always order it when we go to The San Angel Inn, and it is always fantastic!
 
:thumbsup2 to your great reviews. Keep 'em coming!
Too bad about CG....makes me glad I gave away my recent ressie to a fellow DIS'er who really wanted it. (I was nervous about my 3 young kids misbehaving in there & decided to save it for a future "date night")
We loved the food at Tutto too and can't wait to try Jiko sometime in the near future!
Thanks for sharing!
Gotta go check out your review of the AK now since it's under consideration for our June trip! :goodvibes
 
Hi, Johnsonet:

Great to see you here! I always enjoy reading your posts.

Twins? Wow -- server Michelle really does look great. It's nice to hear back from someone who's also had her as a server.

I will request the cooking place as you suggest -- also, I noticed on the lodge activity sheet that at 4:00 PM most days they have a tour of Jiko for adult lodge guests -- have you ever taken it?

I wanted to do the tour very much but just couldn't seem to get back to the hotel in time each day.

Thank you for your suggestions!
Copper

Thank you for the kind words copperbrick :)

Yes, Michelle is a GREAT server and a really nice person. I also LOVE Karim and Nasser, just to name a few.

I really think you would enjoy sitting at the Cooking Place sometime :thumbsup2

I have actually never done the Jiko activity but my dad did it in 2003 and LOVED it. It has probably changed since then but hopefully it is still worth a try. Maybe someone else will help answer that...

Thanks again for your detailed reviews :cheer2:
 
Thanks for the reviews! We are trying Jiko for the 1st time in Nov- can't wait! To request the cooking place; is that done @ the podium when checking in? Thanks for any info on how to do that!
San Angel has always been one of my favorites! I love the food and the atmosphere!
Glad you had a great trip!
 
... To request the cooking place; is that done @ the podium when checking in?
Yes. You just ask when you check in. Hopefully there will be space available. If not, and you have your heart set on it, as I often do, then you can have a drink in the bar while you wait for spots to open up. They will let you know approx. how much of a wait it will be :thumbsup2 Enjoy!
 
Great reviews - thanks for sharing! :)

Keep in mind tho that like you said, the other guests in the wine room at Jiko can make or break your time there. We are regular visitors and were last there in August. We were seated in the wine room which at first I thought was great. Then we got to experience our neighbors. Since we were the only two groups in there we were more aware of them. It was two families on the long table with 5 or 6 kids between them. The kids were basically well-behaved, but, well, they were kids! And I think the privacy of the room let the parents give them more freedom so they were up and about and chasing each other around the table and such. It took away from the feel of the restaraunt for us and next time we will ask to be seated in the main area.

Jill

Yes, so true! Everyone should keep this in mind.
 













Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE














DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top