hi,
We ate dinner at Boatwright's twice last week. My husband's opinion was that the crab stuffed salmon was a thumbs up and the prime rib a definite thumbs down. My pork with mashed potatoes dinner... I can't remember what it was called... was delicious but the blackened seafood/pasta meal was a little too spicy for me. However, I can now say that I tasted catfish! The kids' meals were standard Disney fare.
I would recommend making reservations if you are going during a busy time. We walked right in on our arrival evening (Wed 2/11) but were glad that we made reservations for Sat 2/15. The place was packed, probably because of President's week starting.
Enjoy your vacation!