Best Itinerary out of San Juan?

[Lollipop's Mom]

I am stuck between the Jan 14/18 and Jan 21/18 sailings.
I can't decide.

About us - Mom 45, daughter 21. Massive disney fans. Gold DCL cruisers.
In ports we enjoy beach time. We are not 'city tour' people really. We like to hit the beach and maybe do some shopping. We come from cold weather Canada and love the ocean!
Below are the itins - any input is appreciated!

Port Guest Ashore Guest Onboard

1 San Juan, Puerto Rico - 5:00 PM

2 Basseterre, St. Kitts 8:00 AM 4:45 PM

3 Fort-de-France, Martinique 8:00 AM 4:45 PM

4 St. John's, Antigua 8:00 AM 4:45 PM

5 At Sea - -

6 Oranjestad, Aruba 8:00 AM 4:45 PM

7 At Sea - -

8 San Juan, Puerto Rico


OR...

San Juan, Puerto Rico - 5:00 PM

2 St. John's, Antigua 9:00 AM 4:45 PM

3 Castries, St. Lucia 8:00 AM 4:45 PM

4 At Sea - -

5 Willemstad, Curaçao 8:00 AM 4:45 PM

6 Oranjestad, Aruba 8:00 AM 4:45 PM

7 At Sea - -

8 San Juan, Puerto Rico 7:45 AM -

 

[mom4fun]

I don't know but the 14th is really starting to go up in price so you probably should just book one.

 

[linetbo]

Second one!

 

[mhconley]

I like the second one. Two ports - sea day - two ports - sea day seems to be perfect. Three ports in a row can seem hectic. We booked the Jan 28/18 cruise that is the same itinerary as the Jan 21/18 except it stops in Bonaire instead of Curaçao. We chose it so we could B2B with the 4 night San Juan to Port Canaveral cruise.

Martin