You can't say packages are not much more than DIY or DIY is cheaper than a package. Every holiday has to be looked at on its own.
Last package we did was Xmas 2008, £580pp way cheaper than I could find DIY but then last year DIY cost us £6,000 for Biz class flights, OKW &
DDP, 3 x 21 day Disney tix, 7 day
Disney cruise. Similar package price was around £12,000.
Also everyones different with choices, I will never fly into Sanford again if I can help it where a lot of packages fly into.
If doing a villa I would want to know the exact villa I was going in but with a package you often don't even know the area never mind which villa.
I also prefer being in control of every part of the holiday myself.
We got stuck in Florida over Easter, had extra 4 days and cost me about £600 (plus 3 days lost wages) which is peanuts compared to the £1,000's I have saved over the years (£6,000 last Aug alone)
The chances of it happening to me again are so tiny I don't worry about it at all.