That sounds about right - all the Atlanta 'natives' that we know (in quotes because I'm not sure anyone was actually
born in this city

) are scandalized that we didn't like it. I'm not a big fan of greasy food, so it was no huge surprise for me, but for my husband not to like it either, well, it's gotta be
really greasy.
In any case, they're certainly not hurting for business, so I'm sure we're in the minority. But I still feel compelled to mention it to other out-of-towners looking for stuff to do, since it gets recommended a lot and our experience wouldn't inspire me to tell people to go there.