Anyone have AIG Auto or Amica

Discussion in 'Budget Board' started by FeeleyFans, Jun 17, 2008.

  1. FeeleyFans

    FeeleyFans Mouseketeer

    Jun 3, 2004
    I currently have my car, homeowner and umbella policy with Allstate. Of course, like everyone else I'm looking to save money. I received lower quotes from AIG and Amica. I was just wondering if anyone has had any experience with either and if you are happy with them.
  2. coneeny4

    coneeny4 DIS Veteran

    Mar 15, 2006
    I have had Amica for my car insurance for about 12 years now and have never had a problem. I have had a few windshield replacements and I have been rear-ended a few times the Customer Service has been excellent.

    I was going to add my homeowner's with them at one time but the price they gave me was around $500.00 more than what I was paying so I did not switch.
  3. Avatar


    to hide this advert.
  4. mom3sonstt

    mom3sonstt DIS Veteran

    Apr 28, 2008
    We used to have Amica - we were very happy with them. We wound up switching to Geico though. When we first priced them Amica and Geico were pretty much the same (a whole bunch cheaper than our AAA Insurance!) Then our oldest turned 16, got a license and a car and the renewal was enough higher on Amica that we re-priced Geico and Geico was less. Not significantly, but our daughter-in-law (I have 2 grown step-sons) worked for Geico at the time so that helped in our decision to switch. She worked for the military division so didn't work with our policy but it was still her company. But if the original question was about Amica and AIG - we had no complaints at all about our time with Amica. :thumbsup2
  5. NHWX

    NHWX DIS Veteran

    Apr 15, 2007
    We've had Amica for 18+ years and been very happy with them. We have both house and auto with them. When pricing them, remember that you get a dividend at the end of a year's worth of insurance. I believe that the auto one was 20% this year.

  6. justplaingoofy

    justplaingoofy DIS Veteran

    Aug 28, 2005
    LOVE AMICA!!! we've had them for 12+ years, and turned our entire family onto them. My husband had a claim with his car and the dealership couldn't stop talking about how great the insurance was to deal with..:moped:
  7. lchadwick

    lchadwick I love my monsters!

    Nov 6, 2006
    Another vote for AMICA. My family has been using them for probably 50+ years. My parents hae ALWAYS had them, my sisters have had them, and I had auto coverage through them for YEARS, as well as homeowners, until I moved to Myrtle beach (they don't write for this area). They did get too expensive for us, last year, and it killed me to have to switch. They are the best with claims - really they are.
  8. 1000th happy haunt

    1000th happy haunt <font color=green>My source is knowledgable, but u

    Jan 13, 2004
    We have AIG. And I used their extra services once. I had a flat a short distance (about two miles) away from home. I called my husband and he picked me up. We called AIG about the flat, and they arranged for someone to come and change my tire for me. We headed back out to my car, and he was already there when we arrived.

    The final bill was---NO CHARGE!! It's included with the cost of the car insurance.
  9. dis2cruise

    dis2cruise Long Island, NY

    Aug 21, 1999
    we too have amica car and home never had a complaint with them!!
  10. Bren's Mom

    Bren's Mom DIS Veteran

    Aug 11, 2006
    We've had AMICA for about 10 years now, home and auto. They are can always get a human being on the phone, customer service reps are pleasant and knowledgeable and we've never had 1 complaint at all about them. We've had to file glass claims twice and that was no problem. And my car was in 2 accidents, one rear-ended that was not my fault and I was injured...and the other my car was parked. They handled the first one and were so great to me...I paid nothing out of pocket except my deductible which was returned to me promptly when they were reimbursed. They handled everything with the other insurance co, my extensive medical bills, etc. And my insurance never went up.
  11. DebMcDonald

    DebMcDonald DIS Veteran

    Aug 26, 2004
    We have Amica. They have been WONDERFUL. Can I tell you how long Amica has been in my family. My grandparents had it and then of course put my mom on the policy, she married my father, they put me on the policy, they divorced and my father and his new wife now have Amica, I have been married twice, both my ex and current husband have Amica and my daughter will as well in two years. We have filed claims with our auto policy and also have a policy on our rental property in CT and were sued over an injury that they fought that down to a very low amount. My father was hit in a parking lot last year while grocery shopping and the hitter accused him of doing the hitting and Amica was wonderful about making sure that the claim went nowhere. We have them for auto, homeowners, and a fire policy on a rental property.
  12. lovepurple

    lovepurple Mouseketeer

    May 11, 2007
    I was just reading an article this morning on AOL money and finance that said AIG is having financial difficulties. That would make me nervous since I have had a home burn to the ground and in the middle of our claim, the company went bankrupt and we never got our full settlement. We have had AIG for car insurance before and had no problems, but we didn't have any claims with them either. We switched from them to Progressive, but just last year have switched to State Farm. I was surprised that State Farm was the cheapest I could find for home and auto, and I have two teenagers on my auto policy, one who has had two accidents.
  13. Muushka

    Muushka <font color=red>I usually feel like I just stepped

    Aug 16, 1999
    Another Amica cheerleader here. I have had Amica since 1978 :scared1: , shows how old I am! And when I signed on, you had to know someone already insured with them in order for them to take you as a customer.

    They don't drop you if you make a claim, they are very efficient, they pay claims without making you jump through hoops. Once I was hit by someone insured with State Farm. State Farm did my estimate and only gave me $850. Using used parts, of course.:( . I called Amica and they told me to go anywhere I wanted to get the car fixed, with new parts, and they would go after State Farm. The car cost $1300 to fix and Amica made sure they paid. Got hit with a hurricane. 1 year after the storm I saw damage to a window (had a cell shade that I had not removed during that period). Amica cut a check for $1500.00, without batting an eyelash. All in all, very satisfied.

    Check out the ins co ratings and you will see that Amica consistently scored one of the highest if not the highest.
  14. happily single

    happily single <font color=royalblue>Left foot first!<br><font co

    Jan 12, 2008
    I also have Amica for auto and home. I am very pleased with customer service. I had two auto claims, one uninsured and one my fault:confused3 and both were handled wonderfully. Luckily no need for the homeowners, but knowing whta a great job they do with the auto made me switch to Amica for homeowners.
  15. paladin

    paladin DIS Veteran

    Feb 21, 2002
    My dad has Amica and loves it. We visited him at Christmas last year and were hit by an uninsured driver. Dad's car was totaled:furious:. Amica handled everything (emergency room bills, rental car, check for destroyed car) quickly and efficiently; he couldn't have been more pleased with their service.

    He has had them for years and always liked them, but is even more satisfied with them now because of their response to this accident.

Share This Page