We stayed at Castlehill for part of our honeymoon in something called Harbor House. We have other names for it, but they would be censored on this board. The main inn and the grounds were wonderful, but this place was an absolute dump. It's hard to believe that a place as nice as the inn would even rent unsuspecting people rooms in such a place. My dh was devastated.
Fortunately, it was only a part of our honeymoon and the next place was wonderful. Funny story--when we arrived at our next stop, Nantucket, the desk person at the hotel said that we would not be in the main house but rather in the Garden Cottage. My dh almost died -- flatly refused to go anywhere except the main building. The flustered clerk assured us that it was one of the nicest rooms they had. Sure enough, our room turned out to be an entire floor of a little three-story victorian cottage surrounded by gardens. The room was beautiful, and they had champagne waiting!