I just got off this cruise as well. I'm missing a few pages from the Navigators, but, in case its helpful, here was the nightly breakdown:
Sat/Day 1: Embarkation - Cruise Casual/Standard Rotational
Sun/Day 2: Sea Day - Formal/Standard Rotational
Mon/Day 3: Sea Day - Cruise Casual/Standard Rotational
Tues/Day 4: Tortola - Pirate Night (All Ashore - 7:45/All Aboard - 6:00)
Weds/Day 5: St. Thomas - Princess & Pirate Night (All Ashore - 7:45/All Aboard - 4:00)
Thurs/Day 6: Sea Day - Semi-Formal/Capt Gala (aka lobster night)
Fri/Day 7: Castaway - Cruise Casual/See Ya Real Soon (All Ashore - 9:45 (closer to 9:30)/All Aboard - 4:45)
It was an amazing cruise - I loved Tortola and St. Thomas. I highly, highly recommend Aristocat Charter on Tortola. We did not book it thru Disney but it was by far the best excursion I have ever been on. It was very professional and they keep the sailings to under 20 people (including kids). It was a full day sail and we had an amazing time. You can look them up on tripadviser.
Did your aristocrat charter include Norman Island & Indian Trip?