We thought about doing after hours back in January, but someone signed us up for the DVC party so free

And I was playing with the numbers and it looks like it makes sense for us to upgrade to at least one AP, because we want MM for this trip. The cruise trip will involve one day at Epcot for sure, could end up being 2 day tickets, possibly even PHs. But one AP plus one 7 day PH plus one day Epcot ticket for next summer is the same as buying the tickets for both of us plus MM, after assuming some AP discounts. Getting us both APs is about $260 more that's not needed unless we can fit in another trip, but I don't know that we can with Zack's vacation time. And then having 1 AP would save about $65 on after hours tickets, but my understanding is we have to upgrade tickets in person, which means we couldn't do that until that week. Or Labor Day weekend, as I've been kicking around a trip idea for that...

I over-analyze!
I do have some cashback on another card, I just remembered. I basically only use it to redeem for Landry's gift cards when we've been to Yak n Yeti

My universal webpage is not being cooperative... when I try to look at ticket prices, HHN or regular, the calendar doesn't come up to choose specific dates.
Here's another weird thing with Tiffin's... they are open to book before Sept 14th, and after the 25th. And you can book normal reservations during our trip, it's just the packages that are saying to call