I can see both sides of the coin here! Friendly pirates is great when you have a group of people playing together who know the rules. It works well and everybody gets great credits.
It becomes difficult when some of your players need to leave or you happen to be on at a time that none of your regular players are on, which I believe is the situation described in the first post by Jegrezo. Then it becomes extremely difficult to join a game because everybody else is all set and they do not need an extra player. Another problem develops when you have so many friends playing and you cannot make teams large enough. Splitting the teams to groups of six often works well and usually can incorporate the extra player.
I don't think it is anyone's intention to be rude and I know some people are so desperate to start the game as quickly as possible that it is often difficult to get in that "sorry for the boot" before starting. I know that if I try to take the time to write that, I end up with those random people who will continute to jump in even after we have tried to tell them it is a friendly game and then verbally attack the group. Now I know that Jegrezo never does this and I also happen to know that she does not boot either, so I understand and feel her frustration.
I was on and off yesterday, mostly off due to some major internet problems. When I finally got back on, my original group was already in games with other players, but I quickly found a new group to play with. After I disconnected yet again, I got back on but all the groups were pretty full. My solution was to play random battle games. While the credits were not as great, it was still giving out the extra points for the win so I would average 350-400 a game. Still pretty good.
With all that said, I get booted from pirate games ALL THE TIME!! Whether it is battle or flag, I seem to be the one to boot. Sometimes because the players think I am too good at battle and don't want to play against me, sometimes because they get mad that I "run" when in fact I am trying to get ammo and health (please, will these players ever understand that I have to supply my ship?). But for whatever the reason, I tend to get booted from games more often than not. It no longer bothers me at all. Sometimes it is actually funny because I sometimes end up on the opposite side of the player that has booted me and I can guarantee that I totally enjoyed beating the pants off of them.
It is easier for me to play on double battle days. Since I have not found a way to play "friendly" battle, nor have my friends-games are easier to join over all.
I think the real solution here is to just make all pirate games double every day of the week, then there would not be this desperation of joining in specific games on specific games. It would give everyon the opportunity to earn good credits. I mean, if they continue to sell magic at 10,000 credits a pop, they need to improve the credit earning factor as well.