It probably depends on what they like. I always like to stay in the world so I can park my car and take the buses everywhere. I have been to the All Star's and they are nice . I have never been in the Lake Buena Vista Resort, there is a chance that they might have bigger rooms. They will not have the Disney theming that makes the All Star's special. I have kids so that's important for us. My parents would care less however and enjoy the variety of cheaper eating options off property. My suggestion is to ask what is important to them. All Stars are really neat and convenient, but not the fanciest in the world. Hope that helps a little bit.