I’ve always been a die hard boardwalk fan, since we joined dvc there in 1996, but I’ve been finding it hard to defend my stance that boardwalk is better than beach club lately. Boardwalk had the edge when you used to be able to use the yacht beach pool while staying at boardwalk, but that is no longer allowed, so now boardwalks slightly better location is superseded by beach clubs far superior pool (best in Disney world). Boardwalk has a shorter walk to Hollywood studios and far better views. Beach club was an after thought that was just shoved in a parking lot when the boardwalk villas were so popular and they wanted to add more dvc villas to the area, so the rooms don’t really have a view of much. The location is nearly identical though. Slight difference in the rooms that I’ve noticed: no ceiling fans at beach club, and I have been able to hear the mechanics of the elevators in every beach club villa I’ve stayed in for some reason. I’ve heard both of those complaints from others too. Obviously super minor complaints. Still one of my top favorite resorts for sure.
Have fun!