I have no idea why the seller was selling. The closing costs were in addition to the $70. Our deal was as follows;
50 @ $70 = $3,500
$375 closing
$200 2003 dues
$4,075 ($81.50 per point vs $84 from Disney)
Also, keep in mind that we received all 2002-2004 points which is 100 points more than I would have received from Disney. If you value these at $10 then my cost drops dramatically vs. Disney. Also, Disney would have made me buy 150 pts and this way I can get in with only 50 pts. I may get another 50 pts at BWV/BCV.
I know that resale deals pass ROFR at $58-$60 at VB and $63-$65 at OKW (depending on UY). I expect that without the extra points you could get VWL/BCV/BWV for ~ $65.
We submitted our contract to Disney on October 1st and we closed November 10th.