I too have looked at both these tour groups, and am leaning towards Disney. When I have asked this comparison before, I only get positive comments for either company, it doesn't seem as though anyone has taken both family tours. From a money standpoint, when you look at the meals and number of nights, the Disney tour seems like a better value. The accomodations seem nice at both tours. There is more feedback on this site than the Tauck boards, which are on Tauck's website. While I enjoy Disney, I am not a huge Disney fanatic, so I'm not so captivated by the "Disney" component. In fact, my husband was worried that the Italy tour would be made into a "Mickey Mouse" adventure, but I have been assured on this website that was not the case. I think we should be glad both companies are available, a little competition in the marketplace can only be a good thing.