Uh, being new to the DIS and all (have not been posting much until recently) I do not know you yet ChiaBob. I do know SirpeanutMc however. I met him in the game a while back, and he has been on my friend's list ever since.
About a week ago (give or take a few days, I don't remember exactly) he came to me and said he made a mistake when in trade with someone. He said he put his inferno in the trade window and clicked accept before he meant to. The way he told the story, it seemed as if he did not think that the other player tried to trick him into trading the pin, just that he (SirpeanutMC) made a mistake by pushing accept. He did say that he asked for the other player to give it back, and the other player said no way and quickly left. He was VERY upset about it, and he said he was crying. I think he is rather young, maybe 12 years old. He also could not remember the other player's name at the time. He has talked about almost nothing else with me since this happened: how sad he is he lost his pin, how much he misses his pin.
Now, I am writing this post not to flame you ChiaBob, nor to take his side. I just feel that his side of the story deserves some air time, since you have named him here: as he is not a member of this forum, he will not have seen this post, and will not know to come here to defend himself. I will inform him about the post and hopefully the two of you can get a dialog going about the incident and get it resolved.