A while ago I purchased some pins on EBay with the intention of NOT trading them. Then recently, I bought 10 more so that I could use them as traders. It was just a grab bag type auction and I could have gotten anything. To my surprise, most of the pins were pretty great! I put together my lanyard tonight with all the pins - keepers on the left, traders on the right.
These are the keepers
From top down - Chip and Dale with a Zebra Dome, Chip Head, Chip and Dale with a Disney "D", Dale, Stitch in heart boxers
Stitch again, Elliot from Pete's Dragon, a Green Monorail
And the traders
Nemo, Goofy in a Boat, A Siamese cat from Lady and the tramp (I think?), Jack Skellington, Grumpy
Ariel, Huey or Duey or Luey (who knows!)
And of course, my biggest pin and definitely a non-trader, my Around the World Segway Pin
The ones that I had bought for myself as keepers were the Chip and Dale Zebra Dome, Chip Face, Chip and Dale in the D and the Nemo Pin. The reason Nemo is a trader now is that it was supposed to be a Squirt pin, but the seller sent the wrong one.
It was a hard choice to make when I picked the traders. I like most of the pins actually, but some - like Jack Skellington and Grumpy - while I would normally have kept those pins, or even traded for them, I would have liked them in a different style than what was in the grab bag. So hopefully I can find some adequate replacements at WDW!