What is your Favorite Broadway Musical and why? For me I have 3. It is way to hard for me to choose The Classic One is West Side Story, although I have never seen it on broadway I have seen this production done several times and have played Anybodys in it and it is totally awsome. The Other Two are more Modern: The Phantom Of The Opera another I have never actually seen on broadway, but saw the off broadway cast and the music and songs is just awsome. And Rent I have seen this production the voices of all the cast were just totally awsome and the whole experience was fantastic.