Wow Sheila, thank you for all of the information. I have not been to Nantucket since 1973, but often dream of getting back there. I think if I ever see a week for September or October, I will grab it. I just love that place. Have a wonderful vacation!
We have been here for the Columbus Day week a couple of times. It's a great time to visit. The weather isn't too cold and there are great deals as all the stores close down for the season. The Hospital Thrift Store had half off day while we were here the last time, then gave most of the leftovers away the next day. (They reserved a few high dollar pieces, one or two of which we had our eye on.) I grabbed books until my husband threatened to leave me on the island to make up for all the weight from the books. It was hard to resist. They had a whole room of relatively new books for the taking.
You'll see a lot of changes since 1973. We skipped more than ten years from the late eighties until about eight or ten years ago. Things are different every time we make the trip.
I think the website for the resort is www.tristrams.com. If that's not it, Google will find it for you. Rentals in September and October should be pretty reasonable. If not here, then there should be other availability if you look around. If you stay in town, you wouldn't even need to get a car unless you just wanted to explore the far flung areas of the island.
Very sad to be leaving the island at noon tomorrow.
Sheila