Swimming with stingrays - cozumel or grand caymen?

[jasta]

For those who have done it, which island is better for swimming with the rays?

 

[wiigirl]

My vote would be for cozumel...I just found it to be a more relaxing and enjoyable experience.

Both are pretty great experiences.

 

[scrapbookmomma74]

GRAND CAYMAN all the way!
Our favorite excursion is the "Island Tour with Stingrays", which will take you on a van tour to "Hell, Grand Cayman", then to the Sea Turtle farm, and finally, to a boat to take you out to the Stingray Sandbar. We have done this excursion 3 times, and have not been disappointed any of the times.

 

[hamm1207]

My vote is for Grand Cayman- Sting ray city excursion.

 

[Happy100]

We have only done String Ray city on Grand Cayman so I can't compare the two but it was great. Tons of Rays and each of us even got to hold one and kiss it.

It didn't disappoint at all.

 

[bfamily5]

Don't want to hijack, but what about Castaway Cay? Is this experience good there too? TIA