We want to do a 7 night over Thanksgiving 2014. We've only been on a 5 night Dream Double Dip so we haven't seen any of these ports or either ship. Here are our options... Fantasy Eastern ~ St. Maarten/San Juan/Castaway Cay (Sat-Sat) or Magic Western ~ Key West/Grand Cayman/Cozumel/Castaway Cay (Sun-Sun) Both are about the same price so that isn't an issue. Our DD will be 11 years old, no siblings so she spends a lot of time with us (might do Edge, but didn't love the club @ 9 years old). I'm sure they'll have Christmas activities planned, which we are looking forward to. We don't go to the adult areas, so that is also not an issue although we will do Palo brunch. I know either one will be a great trip. Our plan is to do all 4 ships (Wonder, Alaska, Eastern/Western on the ship we don't chose this time) if that makes a difference. We like the thought of flying into MCO.