Rank the Disney Hotels!!!

[JimmyMcG]

long Long LONG Overdue!!! Get your posts in!!! I'll update the list!!!

 

[maryj11]

1. Poly
2. WL
3. Por
4. Csr
5. Pop
6. Asm

 

[threelilbears]

1) Grand Floridian
2) Polynesian
3) Beach Club
4) Yacht Club
5) AKL

 

[SoScary'09]

DS
1. CR
2. Poly
3. BC

Me
1. Poly
2. BC
3. CR

 

[SoScary'09]

ugh double post sorry

 

[peterox]

1. WL
2. AKL
3. POR

These are the only 3 resorts we have stayed at so far!

 

[AudreyLovesTheMouse]

1. Grand Floridian
2. Poly
3. Wilderness Lodge

 

[AriesAriel]

Okay...It's LONG overdue but I’ve been busy planning our own Disney Trip this August!!!

At this point, I have 258 different lists. As I did previously, I've done two results. The first list is according to the average rank by those who responded. The second is based upon percentage of people who selected that resort as their number one pick (please note that the percentages won't add up to 100% since some people did not rate every particular resort). Also, a couple of people have asked...I am lumping together DVC Villas with their hotel counterpart. I'm assuming that each person would pick his or her preference between the two. If you ranked both, I gave it the higher ranking of the two for computation purposes.

Average Rank:
Polynesian-2.465
Yacht Club-2.776
Animal Kingdom Lodge-3.053
Grand Floridian-3.141
Wilderness Lodge-3.286
Beach Club-3.420
Boardwalk-3.538
Contemporary-3.794
Old Key West-3.933
Port Orleans FQ-4.424
Port Orleans Riverside-4.524
Saratoga Springs-5.276
Art of Animation-5.594
Coronado Springs-5.684
Swan/Dolphin-5.724
Fort Wilderness-5.857
Caribbean Beach-6.010
Pop Century-6.011
All Star Movies-7.446
All Star Music-7.483
All Star Sports-7.795

(I only received seven responses including Shades of Green (two ranking it as a 7, two as a 2, one as a 4, and two as a 5). I didn't feel this was enough responses to have a sufficient sample to include it in the rankings. Ideally as more rank it though, I can include it.)

Based on Percentage of Response ranking the resort as their number 1

Polynesian-40.945%
Boardwalk-27.957%
Yacht Club-27.586%
Animal Kingdom Lodge-27.481%
Wilderness Lodge-26.948%
Old Key West-26.667%
Grand Floridian-17.949%
Beach Club-17.647%
Port Orleans Riverside-14.400%
Contemporary-11.34%
Fort Wilderness-9.524%
Art of Animation-6.250%
Port Orleans FQ-5.263%
Saratoga Springs Resort-5.172%
Dolphin/Swab-3.448%
Coronado Springs-3.061%
Caribbean Beach Resort-0.990%

Keep posting your updates and I'll keep updating the posting!!!

Thank you for this!

 

[Tulles]

Bump

 

[julluvsdisney]

1. Poly
2. Pofq
3. Por
4. Pop
5. Asmu

 

[Lee & Kerry]

POFQ
CSR
CBR
ASMR
POR
Dolphin

 

[3DisneyFanz]

AKL
Pop
AoA
POFQ
Dixie Landings
CBR
AS




CS - distant last place

 

[carlymcqueen]

1. AKL
2. SSR
3. POR
4. CBR

when we go in 2017 we will be staying at the contemporary and I believe it'll make the top 2!

 

[Fantabulously Cherry]

I've only stayed at 3 (visited almost all of them), but here's my ranking of the ones I've stayed at:

1) POR
2) POP
3) FWC

 

[Happyjen27]

1) CR
2) Poly

(those are the only 2 I've ever stayed in. I'm working on getting more resorts under my belt though!

 

[Andrew015]

WL
Poly
GF
CR
BW
YC/BC
Swan/Dolphin
AKL
SSR
POR/FQ
CBR
Everything else...

 

[DVCjj]

1. WL
2. BC
3. Bay Lake
4. Swan/Dolphin
5. BW
6. YC
7. POR
8. CBR
9. OKW
10. AKL
11. Poly
12. CR
13. GF
Have not stayed at Values.

 

[becky15]

1. WL
2. BC
3.YC
4.GF
5.Poly
6.AKL
7.BWI

 

[clapton]

1.GF
2.BC
3.BWV
4.CR
5.WL
6.BLT
7.Poly
8.AKL
9.Dolphin
10.SSR
11.POR
12.POFQ
13.CBR
14.ASMU
15.All Star Sports
16.CSR

 

[AllieBoo]

Yacht Club
Poly
POFQ
Coronado Springs
POR
Caribbean Beach
All Star Movies