pulling kids out of school to cruise...

Discussion in 'Disney Cruise Line Forum' started by dnice416, Jun 6, 2013.

  1. DeniseMarie526

    DeniseMarie526 Whenever you pack your bags, never forget the pixi

    Joined:
    Jan 1, 2013
    Messages:
    231
    I have pulled my children out of schools for vacation. I normally speak to the teacher to try and obtain some educational activity to complete. Last year my DS had to do a travel journal while at WDW. Worked out great. But of course I also allow my children to call out,of school two days a year as long as they are maintaining good grades. I work hard at work, I get benefits like sick days and holidays. Why shouldn't they...lol
     
  2. Avatar

    Google AdSense Guest Advertisement


    to hide this advert.
  3. PATTERSON PARTY OF 3

    PATTERSON PARTY OF 3 Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    Jan 13, 2013
    Messages:
    118
    Family Vacation is a must in our house, it keeps our family bonded. A week of no stress is the best quality time a busy family can spend. We pull our DD (10) twice a year for vacation. Spring & Fall. ... Yes I know most schools in the US get a spring and fall break so why do I let her miss 5 days of school the week after each? The answer is simple........I am an accountant. My daughter's school spring break falls the same week every year...April 15. As for fall break same time every year.... October 15. ( the day extensions are due)... I can not take off 2 off my busiest weeks of the year. Because majority of my clientele are businesses (who generally always file extensions) I can not go in the summer months either. Just not possible. She goes to a private school now and it is not an issue. She was in a Public school and they are strict on absences also but I talk to the teachers, they gave her double the home work the week before each break and off we go! I had to notify the district attendance coordinator in writing and we never received a nasty letter. I don' t feel we are sending the message that vacation is more important than school. Every situation is different, people tend to only think of there personal situations on a question such as this. It is not a financial issue for us, it is a time & professional issue.

    That being said... I do know a family that takes 4 cruises a year that they do take their kid out of school for. They do not make arraignments for missed school work and usually no one but the child talks to the teacher about the fact they will be absent. They also feel that the missed assignments should not count since the child was absent. I do find that irresponsible.
     
  4. clarkshel

    clarkshel DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Aug 21, 2012
    Messages:
    556
    I feel that it isn't a big deal. We pulled my grade 3 son out of school for two weeks last year for our cruise and WDW. My wife used to teach grade 8. She thought it was for when a parent oiled their kids out of school. She would ask them to keep a journal of their trip to review with the class when the kid got back. I think kids get more out of a family vacation than they would in a week or two of school.
     
  5. jjje

    jjje One time I saw a guy wear cut-off jean shorts to d

    Joined:
    Nov 13, 2012
    Messages:
    692
    Every year my kids miss between five and ten days of school as we take family trips and vacations. We like traveling in the off season because prices are better and the places we like to go are less crowded. It works for us. My kids are both doing extremely well in school and they both do work far above their actual grade level. Honestly though even if they didn't I would still pull them out since I think there is a lot of value in family vacations and going to new places. You won't get a consensus on this question. Everyone is just doing the best they can for their families and that doesn't always mean the same path for everyone. :)
     
  6. luv2sleep

    luv2sleep DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Aug 15, 2011
    Messages:
    4,851
    I pulled my son out of kindergarten for a 2 week cruise. He did fine academically because I had to do independent study with him while we were gone (I'm in CA). He didn't do as well on a social emotional level though. He was very disrupted and out of sorts for a month afterwards. Took a whole to adjust. He has some mild special needs including sensory issues. I'm tempted to do it again but I'm not sure if he would do well after we return home. Anyone else here dealt with adjustment issues after pulling out academically well performing children?
     
  7. yaddakal

    yaddakal Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    Jan 29, 2009
    Messages:
    417
    Our school k-4 allows 5 excused days. We pulled them out this year. It's a personal decision because honestly it is so pricey to go in summer or at Easter:(
    Our third grader had quite a but if make up work.
    Our next cruise we hope to take in summer to avoid makeup work ..but then our son will
    Be in middle school.
     
  8. cris0809

    cris0809 Might be why the rum is always gone

    Joined:
    Apr 22, 2009
    Messages:
    1,714
    This is a pretty good description of my entire school life. For example, we took two weeks to go to Paris and Switzerland while I was in high school. I am the oldest of four kids so they pulled one out of HS, one out of MS, and two out of ES. We all were expected to do all of our school work plus a project while we were gone. Plus reading of course.

    My parents never chose to dismiss an opportunity for their kids to see the world because of school. They knew knowledge is something you gain by having many different experiences. However, if we had not done our work as instructed, and well, we would lose that privilege.

    You have to know your kids.
     
  9. sippican

    sippican Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    Feb 2, 2013
    Messages:
    257
    As a retired educator and administrator I need to add my two cents. First of all, I am NOT opposed to children missing school for an occasional family vacation. I do think four weeks out of the year (180 days in our state) is excessive, over 10% of the school year. Please realize that checking with the teacher for approval does little other than placing him/her in a difficult spot. Of course they are going to give their blessing, what other choice do they have, other than to risk a positive relationship with the family? Teachers are expected to prepare work in advnce, then catch up the child, if needed (make-up tests, homework, new concepts presented during the absence, etc). These tasks are to be accomplished in their free time, or class time (possibly taking away from the educational time of other students including yours). Teachers do this all with a smile because they are who they are and I thank them abundantly for that. If you think that they have maybe 25 students in their class, and half of those take five days of vacation time, that's 100+ days of extra work to prepare or cover, in addition to the absences for illness. In my previous district, teachers were not required to prepare work in advance of unexcused absences, but would present a packet of missed work upon return. We did classify absences as excused and unexcused. In this age of school accountability and merit pay for teachers, attendance may become a relevant factor in the standardized testing score game. (in fact in some states distrct school attendance is figured in as part of the school ranking).
    One can never discount the benefit of life experiences and family time. Of course, your children are your own and you are free to make decisions on their behalf. I hope to just point out that the family vacation impacts the classroom community. It simply wouldn't hurt to send a special thank you to the teacher who takes on the added responsibility and make sure to ask if there's anything you can do to make it easier.
    That being off my chest - we take our dear grandchildren out of school for vacations. The only valid reason we can give is because it's less busy during those times :dance3:
     
  10. owensjro

    owensjro DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Feb 15, 2007
    Messages:
    932
    We pulled our daughter out for the East bound TransAtlantic two years ago and it was definitely worth it. Since it was at the end of the year we worked with the teachers and got her final assignments as well as a test she would be missing. She did her assignments and we administered the test on the ship and then emailed the results back to the teachers.

    The trip itself was very educational and was a great opportunity for our daughter and us as a family.

    Jim
     
  11. hrhdhd

    hrhdhd Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    May 9, 2010
    Messages:
    257
    Thank you for this comment. I hate reading about how weeks of class can be made up with some handouts.

    Obviously parents can do what they want (and they are, based on reading this thread), but few of them think about the larger consequences--on the other students in the class; on the teacher, who is expected to cheerily provide "makeup work," which can't possibly represent what the child missed; and on the school district, which is charged with educating students and complying with state laws about attendance or losing funding.
     
  12. feelthenspeak

    feelthenspeak Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    May 12, 2013
    Messages:
    179
    Woa...I think you should breathe.
     
  13. Ssamara28

    Ssamara28 Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    Mar 29, 2011
    Messages:
    236
    I vote for pulling them out of school. We get two back to back days off of school in October so I try to work around that schedule. So we are gone six days but she only misses two days. You only live once and if you are blessed enough to really vacation. I say go for it. She would only miss one day but its to expensive to fly back on a Sunday.
     
  14. martinm

    martinm Grumpy Old Man

    Joined:
    Mar 20, 2013
    Messages:
    209
    I'm taking my 16yo DD the week after Thanksgiving this year.
    I was concerned about her school though. She had to apply to her school like going to college. She has to do some homework on Thanksgiving break to not have any on the cruise.

    When I was a kid I had to be dieing to miss school.
     
  15. sippican

    sippican Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    Feb 2, 2013
    Messages:
    257
    Yes, this is the viewpoint I was trying to represent. It's the side that most don't see or understand. It impacts more than just that one student.
    I did find that most families made these choices sparingly and with sincere consideration. But in truth, unless your work schedule ONLY allows vacation during school time, the real reasons are usually financial or crowds. The wonderful educational benefit and family bonding can take place during the many school breaks during the year. Most are just too afraid or embarrassed to say, "I'm taking a vacation now because it's cheaper and I don't want to deal with tons of other kids."
     
  16. everydaymathchick

    everydaymathchick DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Jul 5, 2008
    Messages:
    1,489
    Depends on you & your child. Are they a good student? Are they self-motivated, so they can make up the work without much struggle?

    As a high school teacher, I don't mind parents choosing to take kids out when they plan ahead and help their child to get caught up quickly.

    I, myself, have taken personal days to go to WDW, and no one has even blinked. I once took a week, but I had a math certified sub who taught my class in my absence. I always leave amazing plans & pick a great sub. If I can choose to do this, and the district is ok with it, a parent should have that right too. :)
     
  17. su_A_ve

    su_A_ve DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    May 15, 2008
    Messages:
    4,188
    It depends...

    We pulled DS16 and DS12 for a week every year until DS16 got in high school. During HS, we pulled DS16 3 days max.

    Of course, DS16 is a straight A student and got all his HW ahead of time and did it while we drove south (from NJ).

    DS12 is high functioning ASD, so I plan on taking him out for a full week once he gets into HS regardless. For him, it is a very well needed break. He can't tolerate the heat much and we need to go during off season.

    In years past when DS16 entered middle school I mentioned to the teacher that we would pull him out for a week in the fall - I was going to a convention in WDW - and she said "GO FOR IT!!!".
     
  18. Presley

    Presley Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    Apr 23, 2011
    Messages:
    159
    My first instinct is to say taking off a little school time for a family vacation is much more valuable than not, if that is the only time that you can take a vacation. I'm thinking of it as a once in a lifetime trip, though.

    Our district lets the kids enroll in homeschool if they are going to miss a week or longer. They can do the work before they miss or while they are missing. We have never done that, but if I was going to take my son out for a week or longer, I'd do that for sure. My son is an above average student. That wouldn't have worked for my daughter who has ADD. For her missing a couple days would be like missing a month.:eek:
     
  19. hrhdhd

    hrhdhd Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    May 9, 2010
    Messages:
    257
    And you should be a teacher for a year.
     
  20. Galaviz

    Galaviz Earning My Ears

    Joined:
    May 5, 2013
    Messages:
    56
    Would your child take time out of college to go on a family vacation? Though it seems like a majority of responders feel it is ok to take their children out of school, reality is I will have 1-3 students do this each year....very small minority. Do I have a problem with it as an educator. For the most part, no. Depends on each individual student and family support they each receive.
     
  21. cmwade77

    cmwade77 DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Jul 1, 2005
    Messages:
    4,011
    I could see 4 weeks being excessive, not sure where that came from? Maybe a post I missed?

    But one or two weeks is not that big of a deal in the grand scheme of things. And yes, it could impact the teacher (although, it shouldn't impact that much, if lesson plans are prepared enough in advance).

    As far as school ranking, to be blunt, I don't really care if it affects the school's standardized tests or not, that's their problem, not mine. The same goes for funding, if they can't handle it, they need to push that family reasons become excused absences. Bottom line is employers are required to give time off for family reasons, why not schools? I know schools don't want to hear this, but again, FAMILY is the most important thing we will EVER have and it takes work to keep a family together. Yes, sometimes that work is playing together, but that is still doing work to keep the family together.

    Personally, I like to schedule my vacations around holidays, so that get more time with taking less vacation time, which would also happen to coincide with school breaks in most cases. But, if I needed to, I would not hesitate to pull the kids out for a week or two. If I had to, I would put them on independent study (which the school is apparently required to permit in our state) or, if the school doesn't permit that and was being insistent that they can't miss, as I said before, I pull the kids out and homeschool them.
     

Share This Page