Ok, little cheesy, but hopefully gets your attention and helps me with the dilemma. I'm planning a secret Disney trip, for Spring Break 2014, and going to make this my son (14) & wife's Christmas present. I'm certain I can change it later if my wife prefers a different resort. But hey, the closer I get it to her not having to do anything else the better. And that's why I'll be doing the dinner res & everything else. And I know which of our favs & new restaurants to book, not an issue. But we've stayed off site twice, and at a value level twice. This time I wanted to go moderate. And I'm looking at the Pirate rooms at Caribbean or Royal rooms at Port Orleans. When I consider my son, I lean Pirate for obvious reasons. But then, my wife & I both have a hard time sleeping & I heard those beds are awful. Then I caught a bit of the DIS podcast that seemed to prefer Port Orleans being a better overall choice than Caribbean. At least that was my perception. I was working while listening & my attention was divided, so I might've been mistaken. So the question; has anyone been in both? If so, what was your preference? Thanks guys!