We had a 7 day stay in January, staying on-site, with the Standard Dining Plan,as we are from quite out-of-town and didn't want to deal with the lack of a kitchenette in our hotel. My mother (who is FL resident), brought us STAGGERING amounts of food despite my telling her that we had a dining plan. However, nobody knew exactly how much food that would be *on* said Dining Plan. Now we know better ....
.... About 2 days in, I realized that there was no way we weren't going to be gorged and gluttonous every day by Elevensies. Holy Portion Size, Batman! Half the Snacks they have are what we would consider an actual MEAL in our family. Seriously. A 3 piece beignet Snack? I ate one, my child ate a corner of one and determined it to be too sweet, and my husband was grossed out - "I've heard so many good things about beignets but this is AWFUL! Deep fried bread covered in SUGAR?! Ew, I need to go find a coffee refill." (he drank 2 cups of coffee trying to get all the sugar out of his mouth) In the end, I ate all the beignets with no dipping sauce and moaned knowing we had lunch reservations somewhere in MK in the next 2 hours. *blooooooooooooooooat*
Meanwhile, back at our hotel room, while holding my Resort Refill Mug full of hot chocolate for the 3rd time today (not counting in-room coffee), I'm looking at the 2 flats of water in mini-bottles, the 5 jugs of juice, the 6 six-packs of juice boxes, the dozen bags of almonds/trail mix/peanuts, the 3 giant bags of Goldfish/Cheddar Bunnies, 2 packs of yogurt tubes, a massive pack of jerky, four boxes of cereal, a mega-pack of strawberry Pocky... it took 3 grocery bags to drag it up from the parking lot. How in the world are we possibly going to eat this? Every morning, for the Parks, I pack a water bottle and one bagged snack in a ziploc, strap on the backpack and get ready for more walking. Nobody can finish any TS meal, and we're constantly using Ziplocs and take-away cartons for QS foods.
Using Snacks on the Dining Plan fell by the wayside because there just was no way our bodies could hold the volume of food expected at Disney. we had
42 Snack Credits leftover at the end of the trip.... had to have one carry-on bag flying home that was SOLELY from Main St. Confectionary with all the bags of gummies and cookies and PEZ dispensers...
Knowing how much food your family will eat is key. How long can you press them to wait before absolute point of no return? Will giving into the whining for pretzels while waiting in a 30-minute line ruin the ADR you have in the next 50 minutes? If you tire the kids out too much, will they just pass out in their chairs and refuse to eat the $150 meal? Will they turn into a screamer and a thrower and a kicker?
Will YOU?
And on the subject of beverages.... that water is only a rental. You will have to return it to the Earth sometime or another. Thanks, over-protective Grandma, you constantly offered a drink to my 5-year-old and now we have seen more of each Disney restroom than an actual ride! People do not get dehydration in January in Florida unless they already have health conditions. A child who is already off-the-walls about her Resort Refill mug and 80 flavours of soda-pop (we never drink it at home) and the fancy Mickey straw, does not need more encouragement to drink fluids! If you don't want to spend crazy amounts of wasted time running back and forth to toilets, please just keep the drink intake to its minimum for your Disney stay. Obviously in July, drink everything in sight. But realize that you
will need to plan breaks to see every restroom, before and after entering an area...
Make sure your packed food can survive the heat, being jammed around in a backpack, security poking at it, etc. I definitely agree that a box of Ziplocs in every size will make life so much easier!
Of course my mother justified her crazy shopping by, "but all hotel room fridges, the top is a freezer!" No, Mom, it isn't at Disney. They want you to shop on-property. We ate about 4 packages of food and had to gift the rest back to her.
My advice, if you are convinced that the gluttonous portion sizes in the Dining Plan are not worth the pre-paid stress alleviation, and you truly want to bring your own food, keep it to a minimum. I found that I wasn't ever hungry at any point, it was actually the opposite, and that's terrible when you have to keep up with the family, keep a steady pace so as not to miss any ADR or FP, and you know there's another "load-down" in 20 minutes that you don't even want. Bring the absolute minimum and if your family members suddenly have a magical expanding stomach, that's when you can let them splurge on a 12" funnel cake!
YMMV, but I found that Eating While At Disney is really a last priority compared to all the other things you Have to Get Done. If you crash at the hotel at the end of the day and all you want to do is empty a trail mix bag into your mouth while watching "Duffy's Bedtime Story", it's not a bad thing.