Question - we visited the Boardwalk on a Friday night (7p-8:15) the last week of May and there was only one strolling entertainer with a washboard and whistle. There were no games or street people. We were very disappointed. Did we go at the wrong time, or is this just another area that Disney is cutting back??
The boardwalk entertainers are out performing at varying times during the evening and as everything else at Disney, during busier times the more often the entertainment is scheduled. You can get the times from the Boardwalk front desk.
There is never more than one street act going on at the same time and the acts are fairly spread out.
The games are the midway carney type games that open around dusk. There are about 4-5 of these type games and you win stuffed animals--typical carnival or boardwalk games. There is also a fortune teller, a huge arcade at ESPN, I think a hair braiding booth, pin station, etc.
The boardwalk is a very, very, small Disney sugar coated glimpse of what the real boardwalk was like in AC years ago. So slight that it does not really even remind me, who was born and raised in AC, of the real AC boardwalk! It is just a TOTALLY different atmopshere, so don't go expecting to see a "real" boardwalk, 'cause it ain't gonna happen. BUT Disney's version of a boardwalk is still a very nice place to spend an evening at. For a family it is very nice to have dinner at one of the Epcot resort restaurants--Cape May Buffet is great for families-- and then walk around the whole area including the YC/BC side, get an ice cream, walk over to the bridge to Epcot and catch Illuminations, play the carney games, watch the juggler, etc.
For an adults only party, some of the best WDW restaurants are in this area: Flying Fish, Shulas, Palios, Yachtsmen Steakhouse, so have a nice dinner and then go to Jellyrolls which is a lot of fun or ESPN or Atlantic Dance. Also make sure to take the time to take the very nice walk around the whole area and maybe sit on the beach at YC/BC, the whole area is gorgeous, especially at night. It is a wonderful way to spend the evening.
However....................
As much as BWV/BWI has a reputation for being the hustle and bustle, the noisy party central, etc resort at WDW, this area is very quiet and laid back compared to PI. You can have a very enjoyable time at boardwalk and have a great evening in the clubs if you wish, but if you want a really all out party atmosphere then go to PI. PI can get really wild and crazy especially on the weekends, CM night and if they are having a special event like Latin nights, Mardi Gras, etc.
I have to say. I agree 100% that the boardwalk is the place for a family of nighttime entertainment and NOT PI. PI is totally for adults, I am always amazed when I see people at PI at night with young kids.
So in answer to the OP, both boardwalk and PI have loads to do for an adult or family evening of entertainment, it all depends on what atmosphere you are in the mood for. Sorta sounds like choosing a DVC resort, hun?? LOL!