BACKGROUND: Our last two meals at California Grill have been two very different experiences. On our Anniversary trip in Nov. 2010, DH and I had a nearly perfect dinner here. The food, service, and atmosphere were all excellent and it was by far our favorite Signature meal of the 6 we had on that trip. Therefore it was one of the first meals I booked on my Birthday trip in May 2011. This time though, DD and I had just an okay meal here and it ended up being one of our least favorite of the 7 Signature meals we had then. So would this third experience be a hit like our Nov. 2010 visit or a miss like May 2011??? Read my review to find out.
CALIFORNIA GRILL
SHORT VERSION
Highlights - Filet, Valrhona Chocolate Cake, Great Service & View
Disappointments - Pasta Special
Would we Return? - Definitely
LONG VERSION
My brother-in-law (DH's brother and a Florida resident) joined us for this meal. This was an unplanned addition, as he originally thought he wouldn't be able to see us this trip due to work commitments. However, he called us the night before to ask if he could join us and luckily I was able to change our reservation from a party of 3 to 4 at the Boardwalk Concierge desk without any problem. Anyway, DBIL picked us up from the Boardwalk and drove us to the Contemporary, so happily we did not have to deal with the Disney bus transportation system. We checked in on time at the downstairs desk for our 7:20 reservation and I politely asked if we could wait for a table by the window. After being given a buzzer, we were directed to take the elevator upstairs and then we found some chairs to sit and wait. It wasn't long though before our buzzer went off and we were led to a table next to the windows in the far right section. I think it may have even been the exact same table as we had on our anniversary trip, so I was quite happy!
Here is a picture of the view from our table:
Now on to the food, of which there was plenty! DS started by ordering this:
Rotisserie BBQ Chicken - with chipotle-corn salsa, roasted peppers and smoked cheddar
He politely shared this with the whole table and it was quite good.
For his appetizer , DBIL had this:
Heirloom Apple Salad - Fourme d'ambert, spiced pecans, and apple vinaigrette
I didn't get to taste this but it looked very good and he seemed to enjoy it.
Now DH loves to have soup as an appetizer and the menu only had one soup listed...
Creamy Parsnip and Sunchoke Soup - apple gastrique, truffled goat cheese gourgere (1/2 portion pictured)
He insisted that I share it with him, so they split the portion in half and served us each our own bowl. I really didn't think I would like this but it turned out to be pretty good. The apple gave it a slightly sweet flavor, which made it different from most soups.
For their entrees, DBIL and DS each ordered...
Oak-fired Filet of Beef with Buttered Purple Stokes Potatoes, Broccolini, Pumpkin Seed Oil, and Teriyaki Barbecue Sauce
OUR DISNEY STEAK CHALLENGE - PART IV
DS absolutely loved his meal!
He said the Filet was one of the best steaks he had had in his life and definitely the best of the trip by far. He let me have a small taste and I agreed that it was very good. Although it was slightly larger and thicker than my Yachtsman filet, I still preferred the one at YSH. To be honest though, I think this is due more to the sauce than the meat itself, as I prefer the Cabernet wine sauce served with the Yachtsman filet. Regarding the purple potatoes, DS was a little wary when he saw their color but ended up liking them. I think Purple Stoke potatoes are part of the sweet potato family and he loves sweet potatoes, so I was not at all surprised that he enjoyed these...once he got past their dark purple color.
As for me, I wanted something a little lighter so for my entree I ordered this from the Appetizer/First Course section of the menu:
Crispy Rock Shrimp Salad - with Florida citrus, red onions, soy reduction, and wasabi cream
I really, really enjoyed everything about this salad...the plentiful crispy shrimp, the greens, the fruit, and the soy and wasabi cream dressing. All was delicious! However, this was quite filling so I can't imagine having this as an appetizer and still having room left for an entree. But I loved this salad and would definitely order it again for my Main Course.
Now for the one disappointment of our meal. For his entree, DH ordered the Pasta Special (which was the Vegetarian option)...
Autumn Squash Lasagna - Ricotta Grits, Squash-Apple Hash, Brown Butter Bechamel, and Cranberry Marmalade
I'm not sure what he was thinking when he ordered this, but I suspect he was thinking about the Butternut Squash Ravioli that he'd enjoyed so much at Giacomo's in Boston during our trip to New England last summer. Although the individual ingredients of this entree sound good on paper, in reality when combined they were pretty awful. Since this was a $31 entree, I tried to get him to ask for something else but he felt like it was own fault for ordering it and decided to just grin and bear it.
Ok, now on to better things...of the sweet and chocolate variety.
For dessert, DS and I shared this...
S'Mores Valrhona Chocolate Cake - Warm chocolate cake w/molten center, Tahitian vanilla marshmallow, graham cracker sable, and peanut butter gelato.
Oh my, this was so good! I've had different versions of this cake at the California Grill (last time was with strawberries), but this is definitely my favorite. This version is in my top 3 Disney restaurant desserts, along with the Chocolate Banana Tart from Citricos and the Almond-crusted Cheesecake from Narcoossee's.
For his dessert, DBIL had this...
Gianduja Mousse with Cocoa Nib Tuile - hazelnuts, cappuccino Anglaise, and Bailey's ice cream
Again I didn't get to taste this, but it looked very good and he seemed to enjoy it.
As we were enjoying our desserts and coffee, we had a great view of the fireworks show from the comfort of our table. What a fantastic ending to a very enjoyable meal!
Our server, Jason, provided us with very good service throughout our meal. This combined with excellent food (with only one exception) and a wonderful view of the castle from our table, made this dinner another hit for us!
OUR TRIP TOTALS - STEAKS 6, CAKES 3
NEXT UP: Breakfast Cupcake from Boardwalk Bakery