I think 5 in a one bedroom is pushing it in terms of comfort. Last year we stayed at BWV for nine days with three kids, 4, 8 and 10. It was probably one of the best weeks of all of our lives!! We used a one bedroom and the 4 year old or 8 year old boy alternated sleeping in a sleeping bag on the floor. Although we are not particularly rich it did seem a bit ridiculous to me to have one of my children sleeping on the floor at this resort, which I particularly feel is one of the finest and classiest in the world! After doing it for a week, we will definitely be getting the two bedroom from now on. It seems like a contradiction to crowd and not have a bed for each person and then to feel like we are in the lap of luxury during every other event during the rest of the time during the vacation. We joined DVC to feel special, important, pampered, and comfortable. I am currently planning on using the need for the additional room as an excuse to get more points. These vacations are what we live for, especially us DVCers! It's worth it to me to make sure my kids are comfortable and sleeping on a regular bed throughout one of the vacations that they and we will remember for the rest of our lives! Just my opinion, but I won't be counting people on the elevators or reporting groups of 5 in a one bedroom to the mickey police!