We just returned from a stay at Old Key West and well.......sad to say but I was very underwhelmed! We have stayed at every value except AOA, every mod, and a few deluxes.. Old Key West is one we will never stay at again. The room was bland, and not really that clean. The counter service had the least variety of any resort I have ever been to. The theming wasn't to our liking either. I kept thinking wonder if we should switch to AKL which we loved and stayed at last September. Has there been a resort that after staying there you thought ummm never agin?