After a long day at Hollywood Studios, we boarded a Friendship Boat bound for Epcot. No sooner than had we left the dock, we were faced with a potty emergency. I took Ariel (the subject of said potty emergency) off the boat at the Swolphin, while the rest of our intrepid group ventured on. BTW, the potty trip was a success and we were soon on the next Epcot-bound vessel. Due to my absence from the check-in, the following is based on hearsay, conjecture and speculation. 3/5s of our party arrived at Tutto Italia at around 8 for our 8 pm ADR. The waiting area was packed in like sardines. They called names quietly, one by one in heavy Italian accents. It was quite a struggle to hear which names were being called. Finally, our group was reunited and after a bit of a wait, we were seated around 8:30. Our server was Ylenia, she was friendly and sweet, but a bit overwhelmed. She even forgot the bread and butter we had to request it. Heres what we got:
It was good. But it would have been better if it came out before the apps.
Speaking of apps, DW got the eggplant parm. She enjoyed it.
Mrs. Potts had the kids salad, since Aurora LOVES Caesar salad, but its not on the kids menu and they swapped.
Heres the Caesar salad. As you can see, its not chopped, so it can be a bit of work for the diner and/or their parents.
I had the fried calamari, which was very good.
BTW, they were out of all kids starters, other than the green salad, so no mozzarella sticks for Ariel. I guess they didnt anticipate the effect of free dining.
Entrees
DDs shared the pizza and the spaghetti and meatballs from the kids menu
DW had the Cannelloni al Forno which was excellent
Mrs. Potts had the salmon and was very happy with it as well.
On Ylenias recommendation, I ordered some kind of tortellini, that was not so great and was a bit cold.
Desserts.
I had the mocha tiramisu it was good.
DW had the profiteroles which were really good.
Heres the dessert Mrs. Potts actually ordered. I think it was the Gianduja - Chocolate Torta
Ariels Mousse
Auroras gelato
After we finished our desserts, they comped a piece of chocolate cake and sang happy birthday in Italian to Mrs. Potts. The picture of the cake was blocked by the water glasses.
I rated Tutto Italia 3.5 stars
DW gave it 4 stars
Mrs. Potts gave it 4.5 stars
Total score 12/15 stars
Total cost without DxDDP would have been $214.07 without the wine. IMHO, this is a bit overpriced for the quality of the food and service. I admit, when it comes to good Italian food, I am a bit spoiled being from New York. This place is far better than any of the Italian food chains on I-drive and far superior to Mama Melrose, but if youre not on the dining plan, you may not want to drop this much money for this meal.