We currently have two cruises booked and can't choose between them. We initially booked a balcony on the Wonder at Thanksgiving when the kids sail free offer was announced. My husband is worried about sailing to Mexico and booked us on the Magic going to the eastern Caribbean on the same date. The Magic was more expensive and all he could book was an inside guaranty. We live in Pennsylvania so Florida is definitely easier to travel to, but we have a ton of frequent flyer miles and could use them for either location so airfare is free. Can anyone help us decide? Is the weather better at one location for that time period? We are more active excursions types than lay on the beach types, so I am a little concerned with the offerings in the Caribbean.