We currently have 3 cars insured with Geico, two are 2000 models, one is 1995 so we only carry liability. I have one at fault and one not at fault accident, as well as a teenage driver. Geico is making me pay dearly. We are strongly considering purchasing a new car which would require full coverage. Geico wants an arm and a leg to add this to our policy, but Esurance is quoting HALF the price of Geico. Is this too good to be true? Anyone have experience with Esurance?