This was my first trip back to the Coral Reef since I was a teen. Our party which was on the dining plan was: Myself (35) DH (41) DS1 (16) DS2 (13) DD (1) Appetizers 2 Lobster soups 2 shrimp cocktails The soup was very good, not outstanding but very good. The shrimp cocktails were very good also. Much better than the shrimp we had at 50's Primetime. Entrees 4 NY Strip plates All were ordered medium and all were cooked medium. The scalloped potatoes with cheese served with them were also very good. Dessert 4 choclate waves Wow, is all I can say for these. If you love chocolate you will love these!! Our daughter ordered a chocolate milk and pizza. Which they comped us. Not really sure why, the table next to us also on the dining plan threw a fit because they recieved a seperate bill for their 2 yr old who was not on the dining plan. The manager came out and it was just unpleasant to witness. I wasn't sure if they didn't understand the dining plan or wanted something for nothing. It just amazes me the poeple who think under 3 eats free means all food for under three is free. I mentioned to our server that I was well aware of paying seperate for our daughter and he just smiled and said thank for you but don't worry about it. I must say after reading all of the so-so reviews on this place I was nervous. But in the end this was our overall best dining experience. The food was prepared as requested and was presented well with the right amount of seasonings and flavor. Our sever Alejandro was the best server of the trip. We used 4 table service credits here. Cash total $258.50. 1-10 rating "10"