Yes two VERY different options, however that is what I have it narrowed down to. We are a family of seven (six & a baby) planning our very first WDW family vacation. I'm deciding between a family suite at AOA & renting DVC points for a 2 bedroom villa at BLT. I absolutely adore AOA theming- you are just emerged in Disney, I have read that BLT is more fancy and stuffy, more like staying at a Hilton? I love that BLT has the moneral & it's proximity to the Majic Kingdom. I love that BLT has character dining, although I like the grab & go options offered at AOA. My biggest hang-up is giving up any promotions given (especially free dining) if they are offered Nd I choose BLT over AOA. What would you do!!?