Have stayed at:
MK Resorts: GF(2001), PR(1980), WLV (often), FW Cabin (2003)
EP Resorts: YC (1991), BCV (2002), BWV (often)
AK Area: AKL (2003), CSR (often), ASMovies (once was enough)
DTD Area: OKW (very often), PO-FQ(1990), CBR (1989)
Have not stayed at:
ASMu, ASSp, Pop, CR (although visited grandparents there in the 80's)
Favorites:
WL - ambience (total immersion / relaxation, yet close to many things), family atmosphere, trains
BW - entertainment, proximity to EP/MGM, pool slide
BC - stormalong bay, proximity
Liked all of the resorts, but, like everyone, we vote with our $$ - the best indicator of preferences is a repeat-return. For the last few years, we have been staying two weeks (DVC members - affects choices, but, they would be our choices anyway) and splitting our stay 4 ways:
2 weekend days - moderate (CSR / PO) or AKL
5 DVC (WLV)
2 weekend days - moderate or FW cabins (if having company)
5 DVC (BWV or BCV)
Some years we have a car (facilitates transitions), some years we use car service (airport) and let the bell staff move us from hotel to hotel. It all works - even transporting refrigerate-ables.
Those that did not make a repeat-return, frequent-patron status and why (your reasons may not be my reasons):
GF: Nice room, terrible view; wasn't willing to pay more than $200/night for a preferred view. Just trying it with AP discount one year. We frequent the lobby in the evenings for a glass of wine and music - and you don't need to stay there to do that.
PR: Nice memory from 1980, but the discounts never put it into our price range. Our price range may not be your price range, etc.
CR: Like the concept and convenience, but never cared for the decor.
AKL: Would stay here again for a weekend with the right discount - on the premise that we would get an AP discount for a standard room and hope for a savannah upgrade, since they seem to be common (but NEVER guaranteed!!). Had reservation to stay here again this trip, but for the same price, was able to get Royal Pacific at US (with FOTL benefit). We haven't been to US since 1993, but this is also the first year we have not been able to afford renewing our Disney AP's, so we'll give US another chance. Once a decade won't break our Disney stride too much (unless they actually have created some magical "hooks" since our last visit.)
Best value for the dollar, all around favorite: WL
PS - Disney - if you are listening, consider me a bellweather - I have been a loyal AP holder (since 1995) / DVC member (since 1992) and, due to AP prices, I am voluntarily placing myself under the spell of US for a few days. I am not expecting any trouble (like wanting to go back to US again after 2004), but I did not even consider going there as long as I had Disney AP's to get into a Disney park. I have been writing for years that you need a special AP classification / price for DVC members that more closely resembles Florida residents. We are committed to coming often, I should think you would want us spending all out discretionary vacation dollars in your parks and restuarants - even if it mean fewer AP ticket dollars. The AP / ticket people should be your park / restaurant people's business partners, not an independent business silo attempting to make their own profitability numbers.
Who knows, maybe 2004 is the year my 10-year-old idea will finally make sense to them.....