I wouldn't give up on V&A. As Pakey noted, it is an "all in" price that is only marginally more than an app, entree and dessert at most of the other places recommended here. And if that is still too much, then convert one other TS meal to a CS meal during your trip and move the savings over to a meal at V&A. It will be a lifelong memory. But if you opt to go elsewhere, I would go to bluezoo as my first choice and Citricos as my second. While I think that Il Mulino is a bit better, the atmosphere at Citricos is more conducive for romance. It seems silly, but I prefer tablecloths when I am seeking an anniversary atmosphere. Shula's is too "manly" for me to ever consider taking my lady out for a celebration. Reading a menu off of a football does not scream: "Happy Anniversary Honey".