A review of the Fantasy (August 11 7-night Eastern itinerary)

Discussion in 'Disney Cruise Line Trip Reports' started by SnackyStacky, Aug 21, 2012.

  1. safetymom

    safetymom Super Moderator

    Joined:
    Aug 13, 2001
    Messages:
    40,898
    Thanks for the great review!!
     
  2. Avatar

    Google AdSense Guest Advertisement


    to hide this advert.
  3. kellimomo3

    kellimomo3 Busy mom to 3 prince charmings (maybe someday?)

    Joined:
    Feb 16, 2004
    Messages:
    719
    Hi there. We were on the cruise with you and had horrible service in the MDRs as well. After 4 cruises on the Magic with amazing service we were very disappointed. No allergies in my family so I don't know what the excuse was. Huge language barrier, incorrect items, timing WAY off. Our assistant server was great though!!
     
  4. SoThisIsLove

    SoThisIsLove Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    Mar 1, 2004
    Messages:
    219
    Hi,

    I was on the same sailing as well and we had horrible service in the dining rooms as well. We had the first seating and unless we skipped dessert, we would not finish dinner until 8:00 every night! We missed so much of the family entertainment and character experiences that were scheduled between the 7-7:30 start time. Our servers were very nice and worked hard but I honestly think they are overworked. They looked so tired and upon speaking to many different servers throughout the week.....most said they use their time off to sleep instead of getting off the ship (which I do feel bad about...). We did run into language barriers too....esp with our stateroom host and you could tell he was new. We had a hotel manager outside our room with him many days...and we could tell he was nervous. I also agree with the whole kids running around unsupervised. We had numerous instances of kids running down the halls after midnight and one night around 230 am they were actually kicking people's room service dishes up and down the hallway and slamming them into the hallway walls and breaking them.
    I totally agree with the pool too. We could not find a chair on any sea day on the pool deck and the pools were so crowded and cloudy we did not let our 5 year old swim during the day...we did go on the aqua duck but only at night since during the day the wait was 60 minutes or more. The other thing we were disappointed in was that Nemos Reef was not open later for the little ones. It closes at 7. Many times at night I would not let my daughter go in the pool because there were kids unsupervised in the pool and they were rough. One night in the Mickey pool there were 3 kids....maybe 12, 8 and 6. They were wrestling each other and tossing water at each other with cups. Many people left the pool. I went to cast member and asked if they could help and they did ask them to stop but we were told that they can not ask them to leave the pool! What???? Kids are being rough, bothering other guests, and could possibly hurt themselves and they are UNSUPERVISED and you can't ask them to leave the pool? Totally baffling to me? So instead the children who had proper supervision and were acting appropriately had to leave the pool for their own safety??? I will never understand??? I told my husband I wanted to see how long it would take for a parent to come down to get them so I waited and watched the funnel vision movie. It took about an hour for the parents to show up....and when they did, they were all primped up with cocktails in their hands....they must have been at one of the adult clubs or maybe a Palo dinner....guess they don't believe in kids clubs.....but the kids being so young....swimming alone was not a safe option.
    We were on the Magic the week prior and our experience was night and day. I have to admit I left the Fantasy a little disappointed. Now I fully understand the crew members fears on the Magic. They are so afraid they are going to lose their spots on the Magic and be transferred to the Fantasy. They all are begging to stay on the ship when their contract is up. Many of them are trying to stay under the radar....
    Hopefully Disney can get things together on the Fantasy...it's a beautiful ship. I just hope Disney did not make it too crowded.
     
  5. MickeyEarrings

    MickeyEarrings Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    Jul 1, 2012
    Messages:
    310
    Hearing how incredibly poor St Maarten is may alter our touring plans.... Thanks for such a detailed review!
     
  6. MickeyEarrings

    MickeyEarrings Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    Jul 1, 2012
    Messages:
    310
    Based on the views at the different ports would you recommend a stateroom on the port side vs starboard? Or does it really matter?
     
  7. ddixon1

    ddixon1 Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    Jun 16, 2012
    Messages:
    244
    I repeat: fine the parents/stateroom!

    Such behavior is beyond unacceptable -- it's destructive.

    Of course, we want to permit our children to have some freedom, but not at the expense of all of the other paying passengers on the ship.

    Currently, I keep an eye on my 7 y/o son at all times (when he is not in the club/lab).
    When he is old/mature enough to earn some free time, he will be provided with clear instruction as to appropriate/inappropriate behavior.

    If I were ever informed that he ran up and down hallways, or engaged in any type of destructive behavior, such as breaking dishes, I would have him spend the entire next day confined to the cabin, writing notes of apology to each and every stateroom on our deck (or the deck that he was running rampant), as well as the deck below.

    He would be required to pay, out of his own funds/allowance, for any broken dishes/items (after he cleaned it up, himself).

    He is taught to respect himself, and those persons around him. If he does something wrong, he is expected to make it right. That's it. Before anyone accuses me of being a Tiger mom, please understand that I/we serve up ample amounts of hugs and kisses and and laughter and "I love you"s and all kinds of (specific) positive reinforcement. But bad behavior is not to be tolerated, under any circumstances! My $2. ;)
     
  8. SnackyStacky

    SnackyStacky <font color=9900FF>Disney Addict<br><table border=

    Joined:
    May 29, 2002
    Messages:
    6,801
    I'm very glad it was not just us. My impression is that Disney was not prepared for the extraordinary amount of staff they'd need to work these mega ships. I think it's a combination of under-hiring, the inability to be as selective as they used to be, and frankly a lack of training. I many "insider" blogs, and I know that training has taken a HUGE cut at the parks. I wonder if that's permeating the cruise division.

    I CANNOT fault ANY of the dining room staff for not working. They were working their tails off, and always running around. And I feel for them. But Disney is charging arrogant prices for these cruises, and they need to reflect in the service they're providing. That's why I tried to be as vocal as I could about it. They can't fix something when they don't know it's a problem.

    I was TOTALLY unaware that children were being THAT obnoxious. I did have a run in with a kid in line for the AquaDuck. Now granted, we were there after 9:30 at night, so there was no line. But these kids were clearly exhausted and were being stupid and dangerous. They were frantically running up the steps and tried to push me out of the way. I have really long arms, and was able to put one hand on the left railing, and one hand on the right railing. The kid ran smack into my arm. He apologized and then tried to go UNDER my arm. I immediately told him he was cutting the line and that was not acceptable. He immediately stopped.

    I did also say something to some child who almost took out my daughter while running up the stairs.

    Their economy is 100% dependent on tourism. So definitely go shop. I would either stay right at the pier, or take the $3 cab or $4 water ferry to Phillipsburg.

    We were starboard. On Caribbean/Bahamian itineraries, I always take starboard because you have a BEAUTIFUL view of Castaway Cay. For St. Thomas and St. Maarten, I really didn't find there to be a big difference in either view. It was beautiful any which way you looked! :)

    I have a feeling that any cast member is reticent to approach kids who misbehave, because it would be deemed "bad service". (Like the previous poster who was told they couldn't ask the misbehaving children to leave the pool) All these people who let their children run free and unsupervised on the ship would probably run to Guest Services and complain the minute that one of their children was spoken to by a cast member; let alone if they were to be charged a fee.

    The responsibility to fix this issue is on our society, in my opinion. This one I can't fault Disney for. I brought it up more as a way to say: "Be ready for this."

    Working on the navigators, shopping guides and our Remy menu as I type this! :)
     
  9. Silverfox97

    Silverfox97 PLATINUM Castaway Club

    Joined:
    May 20, 2010
    Messages:
    6,188
    Enjoyed reading about your trip!

    That is AWFUL to hear about your dining experience - OMG! We were on the Fantasy June 16-23 & it was our 6th cruise. Our service was great! We had Daniel from Hungry, who had been with DCL for a long time - I think he said 5 years. He started on the Magic, opened the Dream, then the Fantasy. We had Suthepong (sp?) from Thailand as our asst., who had been on the ship for two weeks. Despite that, Suthepong did a great job - he only had 2 tables to take care of & did great trying to interact with our DD. The head server's name escapes me, but he was very visible & DH & I noticed him working - he was helping out all over. DH has a shellfish allergy, but we don't list it anywhere because he gets tired of talking to chefs......And our dinners began at 5:45 & were done around 7pm every night except the night of the non-Crush Animation show, when we didn't order dessert before the show, so that was closer to 7:20. I would SCREAM if it took until 8pm+ to go thru dinner.

    Anyways, we are back on in December & I hope we don't experience what your sailing did!!!

    On St. Maarten, we did Bernard's Tour. It's not a DCL excursion, but it was fabulous. It showed us both sides of the island, beaches, and it was mostly highlights vs lowlights.....I highly recommend doing that!

    Thanks again~

    Sent from my iPhone using DISBoards
     
  10. SnackyStacky

    SnackyStacky <font color=9900FF>Disney Addict<br><table border=

    Joined:
    May 29, 2002
    Messages:
    6,801
    Here's the navigators and shopping guides. I will send them to the DIS, but I've got them on Google Docs/Google Drive until they're posted.

    Day 1 (Lost the full navigator - this is just the chart with activities and the operating hours for various locations)

    Day 2

    Day 3

    Day 4

    Day 5

    Day 6

    Day 7

    St. Maarten Shopping Map

    St. Thomas Shopping Map

    Because of my wife's allergy, they had created a special menu for her at Remy. It was printed beautifully on some cardstock. We asked for the chef to sign it, and kept it. :) I should also point out the folder is a cardboard envelope. We didn't steal the lovely menu holder. :)

    Remy Menu
     
  11. TDC Nala

    TDC Nala <font color=red>1937, what a year that was<br><fon Moderator

    Joined:
    Jun 22, 2001
    Messages:
    59,035
    Have heard a lot lately about unsupervised children running wild on the cruises and the staff will do nothing about it. Probably until some kid gets hurt. Then they'll start banning stuff.

    My Fantasy cruise is 9/8, glad to hear there is still strong cheese at Remy.
     
  12. Bonniec

    Bonniec DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Aug 22, 2011
    Messages:
    2,777
    I hope you both will write Disney and let them know everything you said. Like one of you said, they can't fix it if they don't know. Unsupervised children acting wild is probably the one thing I am most worried about. My son is too shy and can't handle wild, rude children. I get very angry about it and tend to use the mom voice to kids whether they are mine or not. I'd obviously rather not have a confrontation but when they effect me or my own child, I can't just do nothing. It would bother me if the CMs did nothing.


    I'd never call you a tiger mom. I feel 100% the same way. I'm a big believer in manners.
     
  13. Bonniec

    Bonniec DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Aug 22, 2011
    Messages:
    2,777
    Can I ask another question, do kids run crazy in the concierge areas on any ships? This is one of the reasons why I am considering it.
     
  14. iheartcruising

    iheartcruising Earning My Ears

    Joined:
    Jul 7, 2012
    Messages:
    33
    No. In my experience the concierge floor is pretty quiet. I only have experience with deck 12 on the Dream but I think it was quieter than other areas. HTH
     
  15. wishuponastarforever

    wishuponastarforever <font color=deeppink>I just love coming here and v

    Joined:
    Jan 12, 2004
    Messages:
    1,108
    Amazing Trip Report. I'm glad you had a great time in spite of the servers and unsupervised children.

    If more people complain to DCL after the cruise about the behavior of unsupervised children, perhaps a policy would have to go into effect giving the CMs onboard some latitude. I believe they do not have any authority and need some guidance from corporate. I agree there should be consequences to the offenders not to the other guests.

    Thank you for taking the time to share all your valuable information.:thumbsup2
     
  16. karaintn

    karaintn Earning My Ears

    Joined:
    Mar 28, 2012
    Messages:
    54
    We have Fantasy cabin 6586 booked for April! I was so glad to read your review, but I'm confused about the ladder situation. We have 3 kids so we'll definitely be using the upper berth - our 8 yo ds will be up there. What do you mean that it was OK because your dd is a "little girl"? My son is old enough that I'm not too worried about a short/wobbly ladder, but was wondering if you could give a little more info.

    Thanks so much for your thorough review, I really enjoyed it.
     
  17. dgmommie

    dgmommie Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    Jun 7, 2012
    Messages:
    278
    One of the CM's told me a trick she uses when we were onboard last month. It had something to do with the stars on the carpet - if I am remembering correctly, it was that the top of the stars point to the front of the ship always.
     
  18. SnackyStacky

    SnackyStacky <font color=9900FF>Disney Addict<br><table border=

    Joined:
    May 29, 2002
    Messages:
    6,801
    I asked if it was safe to use since it was just hanging off the upper berth. It didn't touch the floor. The stateroom hostess told me that because she's a little girl, it was safe to use.

    Since she said engineering was aware of the problem, hopefully it's repaired before you cruise. :)
     
  19. Kman34

    Kman34 Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    Jul 27, 2011
    Messages:
    119
    Great trip report...We were on The Wonder last year and Novak was or bartender. He's a great guy and a fantastic bartender. We're so happy that he moved to the Fantasy since we're cruising on that ship in November.

    Bummer about unruly kids, but that's what the bar is for :yay:
     
  20. jezebella

    jezebella MK fireworks in my backyard every night!

    Joined:
    Aug 16, 2005
    Messages:
    886
    We were on the same cruise. Spent every night at Skyline with Novak....so much so you'd probably recognize us. He's our favorite bartender ever after 10 cruises!!

    We didn't have any service issues. Cami and Steve in the dining room were AWESOME. We let our 11 year old daughter go around the ship with her friends, but they were a pretty subdued bunch. Maybe some of the running around you saw was actually instigated by the Tween Club. I know they had several activities where they would send the kids off on scavenger hunts, and things around the ship.
     
  21. SnackyStacky

    SnackyStacky <font color=9900FF>Disney Addict<br><table border=

    Joined:
    May 29, 2002
    Messages:
    6,801
    TESTIFY!

    Could be! If that's the case, they need a counselor to go out with those kids and supervise. Or set the rules before they leave the clubs.
     

Share This Page