We just got off the Magic yesterday. This was our first DCL cruise, but everyone in our party (including the toddler) has cruised on other lines before. I asked everyone in our family what they thought of the trip. DM - "This is the best line I've ever seen for kids. I was very impressed." DH - "Oh my gosh, there were so many kids...." DS - "This is was the Best Cruise Ever! So far..." DD - "Mee Mouse! Mee Mouse!" As our family's trip planner, I have been asked to cancel next year's planned RCCL cruise and book another DCL cruise. Pre-cruise, I wondered why people who tried DCL were so determined to stay with DCL, often exclusively. We're not determined to sail exclusively with DCL in the future, but I agree that for young children, it is the best we've seen. Both our almost 2 year old and our 7 year old absolutely adored it. I'll do more of a comparison later, but I wanted to share our initial impressions.