Hi Su-Lynn!
I'm all caught up, and I've started reading your WDW portion of your birthday trip. Bring on the food!
We had a fantastic time on our SWDAS cruise, and have been back almost a week and a half now. WHAT??!!! Pretty sad when you get post-cruise depression before you even leave - but we had mostly great weather and did a few new things, so it was an amazing time, and it actually didn't even feel all that short. It felt just perfect. I haven't checked with DH about whether he prefers main or late seating, but I could go with either one, I think. I like eating early and not going to sleep on a full stomach, but on the other hand, we actually caught a couple of the late-night adult shows in the clubs while giving our food some time to digest, which we usually miss because we don't generally stay awake that late. (early risers, we are, as Yoda might say) This has been a super trip report, and gave us some good tips to maximize our fun - I hope you continue to write trip reports for many years to come.
I'm also going to be checking out your blog for Hawaii tips, since that is our next big adventure next spring. I'm feeling so lost, since I know nothing, zero, zilch about Hawaii - so I'm just starting to begin my research.
Have a fantastic day!